reapersaurus wrote:
My guess is, you didn't read the discussion. Because you may see that greendan (the gentleman and apparently cool guy that he is that wants to make his reviews better and more valuable to the community) tipped my 1 GG (a not small sum) for the links I posted to him.
Yes, I did manage to read the discussion before posting my comment. That was the reason I posted it.
Quote:
But for your information, what you described is not a review. I think someone should let you know that. A review is supposed to be more significant than a play walk-thru. It mentions such in the Reviewing Guidelines, IIRC.
Well that's your opinion and you're quite welcome to it, and even though Greendan's review may not have strictly adhered to the Reviewing Guidelines you mention, they are only guidelines and not requirements. I for one am extremely happy that Greendan has taken your comments as gracefully as he has and hasn't been put off making further contributions.
Quote:
The thing is that BGG is supposed to be a hobby site, not some sort of academic endeavour striving for truth or meaning. Greendan's review may not have given us any great new insight into The Great Dalmuti, or pushed back the boundaries of reviewing technique, but so what? I wasn't offended by his review - in fact I thought it succinctly and effectively explained the game and his feelings about it. Are the other reviews 'better'? Well yes, in my opinion some of them are, but that's a value judgement and does not diminish or disqualify Greendan's contribution. If his review had been "I hate The Great Dalmuti, it sucks", then I would have had a different attitude to it, but it didn't. And, as I stated in my last post, other BGG-ers may actually find the review to be just what they're looking for, written in a style that they find to be straightforward and accessible. It really all depends on the individual.
If we all sat here trying to write 'knock-out' reviews every time, then BGG would be a lot emptier than it currently is and a lot poorer for it.
And finally, I haven't written a review, so I can't really criticise someone else for having the guts to have a go.
Cheers,
Matt