geek
Rules | Subscriptions | Bookmarks | Search | Account | Moderators
Recommend
19
1 Posts
New Thread | Printer Friendly | Subscribe  | Bookmark
Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: 10_Word_Review [+] [View All]
Joe Grundy
flag
Avatar
0708
Primordial Soup » Forums » Reviews
10 Word Review and Rules Complexity Score
Following are the ten topics most characteristically mentioned about this game in 650 user ratings comments on BGG. Hopefully after 60 seconds you'll know if you want to chase more detail.

"PRIMORDIAL SOUP" IN TEN WORDS:
(Starting with most mentions above average...)
1. Genes/Powers
2. Amoeba
3. Eat
4. Long
5. Theme
6. Combinations
7. Poop
8. Strategies
9. Mechanics
10.Unique


RUNNER-UP TOPIC WORDS:
"Interesting", "Upkeep/Fiddly", "Bits", "Survival",
"Game-Play", "Cute", "Drift", "Evo (a game)"


CONTEXT:

1. GENES
"variable-player powers are just great"
"add a signficant level of complexity resulting in a relatively lengthy and involved game"
"watch your mutation points or the ozone layer will get you!"

2. AMOEBA
"drifting, eating, excreting, fighting and fleeing, dividing, dying"

3. EAT
"a lot of fun try to guide your amoeba to rich sources of food"
"wriggle and drift in the current all in the hopes of feeding or face extinction"
"something about eating other player's poop makes me like this game"

4. LONG
"quite a bit of fiddly dealings with picking up and placing cubes"
"2+ hours is a bit too long"
"a bit slow to start but once players have figured the mechanics things go smoothly"
"nice game to add to the table when a longer lighter strategic game is desired"
"the feeding/movement phase takes too long"
"after a number of games (10-15 in my case) the mechanics become repetitive"

5. THEME
"fits the mechanics perfectly"
"awesome, and great art and gene ideas"
"more here than any lame historical simulation"

6. COMBINATIONS
"however you want to-play, aggressively, defensively, or slyly, you should be able to find a combination of genes to suit"
"definite learning curve here, and some gene-combinations work much better together than others"
"I'm still wondering if there's something like a killer combination"

7. POOP
"One amoeba's poop is another's food."
"poop jokes galore"
"eat poop and excrete poop and when you die you turn into a rainbow of poop"

8. STRATEGIES
"seem limitless with the different combination of cards"
"just enough randomness and strategy to make this one shine"
"seems pretty simplistic considering all the fiddling"

9. MECHANICS
"theme is interwoven well with the mechanics"
"ingenious"

10. UNIQUE
"unique mechanics"
"unique pieces and play"
"unique theme"
"unique gaming experience"


RULES COMPLEXITY SCORE:
13 to start a first game .. 39 to be ready to fully plan ahead
(39 includes understanding 20 gene cards)
(Note: roughly speaking this is a concept count, not strategic complexity)
(Note: 16 of the 20 gene cards are all available to buy at will during the game, and there are 4 upgrade genes. An understanding of all the genes is a strategic advantage. There are variants which reduce this complexity.)

Compare:
Ra: 10 .. 14
Chess: 9 .. 12
Settlers of Catan: 12 .. 19
Puerto Rico: 20 .. 31
Ticket to Ride: 11 .. 11
Bohnanza: 9 .. 10
Carcassonne (H&G): 8 .. 11

I hope you enjoy more "10 Word" reviews
Last edited on 2008-01-16 01:27:00 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
BoardGameGeek and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.