geek
Hot Games
Blackbeard
Agricola
Race for the Galaxy
Galactic Emperor
Puerto Rico
Stone Age
Settlers of Catan, The
Risk
Twilight Struggle
Amazing Space Venture
Through the Ages: A Story of Civilization
Last Night on Earth: The Zombie Game
Pandemic
Power Grid
StarCraft: The Board Game
Arkham Horror
Descent: Journeys in the Dark
Carcassonne
Descent: The Road to Legend
The Devil's Cauldron: The Battles for Arnhem and Nijmegen
BattleLore
War of the Ring
Manoeuvre
Tigris & Euphrates
Arkham Horror - Kingsport Horror Expansion
Conquistador
1960: The Making of the President
Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage
Twilight Imperium 3rd Edition
Aquaretto
Ticket to Ride
Caylus
Race for the Galaxy: The Gathering Storm
Age of Empires III: The Age of Discovery
Tide of Iron
Titan
Commands & Colors: Ancients
Shogun
Clue
Kingsburg
El Grande
Brass
Hanging Gardens, The
A Touch of Evil, The Supernatural Game
Scrabble
Bang!
Galaxy Trucker
Citadels
Risk: Black Ops
Container
Recommend
49
Paul - the
flag
Avatar
0405060708
A closer look at the VG edition of Hannibal

Now that I finally got the game let’s take closer look on it. I should mention that I won’t compare it to the old AH edition as most people have never and will never see it anyway. Besides, I sold my old copy when I decided to buy the new edition. Smart move? Let’s find out…

NB: In this review I have used pictures from the gallery here at BGG instead of taking my own. A big thanks to the people I have borrowed from. If I have used one of your pictures and you would rather that I had not, let me know and I’ll remove it.


The box and what’s in it



Is it a bird? Is it a plane? No, it’s a falling elephant.

The game comes in a fairly big box with a nice finish. The box art is a bit over the top with elephants falling off a mountain and Hannibal looking like a cave man but I still like it. I also like the use of elephants on the back for suitable age and complexity. Nice touch.



When you open the box you find a 10-piece puzzle board map, rulebook, one player aid, two decks of cards, three sheets of playing pieces, two dice, 14 plastic stands and an insert to hold all the components.



Personally I usually throw out box insert right away as they never work in reality. Once you sleeve the cards (recommended) they won’t fit in the insert anymore and the other components will shake loose unless you have the game lying down anyway. As I have my games standing, bye-bye insert.


The dice



The lacquered wood dice are a nice touch, especially the Carthaginian one. I’ll probably use other dice when actually playing the game but I really like them.


The playing pieces



There are not many types of playing pieces in Hannibal. You have hexagonal political control markers (PCs) including tribes, round combat units (CUs) and square city markers. There are some additional information markers for turn, siege status, siege train and current proconsul. In addition to the markers you have a number of generals to be placed upright in the plastic stands.

The playing pieces look good and as they are made of thick cardboard there is a real quality feel to them.


The map



The map is probably the biggest news in the VG edition of Hannibal. It’s a ten piece puzzle board map. I’m not sure what I think about it? It’s of good quality and easy to assemble but how durable is it? Will it still hold after having been assembled 100 times? Normal folding maps have their problems as well, but as I usually play with Plexiglas it’s not that big a problem to me. I guess a paper map à la GMT was out of the question here as VG wants to sell the game to more people than just old wargamers, and with that in mind I think the puzzle board map was a good choice.

The map looks a bit busy though. Perhaps it’s the dual place names on all spaces? I also think Italy especially is a shade too dark. It’s hard to spot the connections between spaces at times.

On the map you’ll also find various tables and leader boxes. There’s an error on the attrition table, it says -1 modifier when crossing a non-Alps pass where it should be -2.


The rule book and play aid



The rule book is nicely done and in colour. The actual rules are the same as the AH 2nd edition rules, at least I couldn’t find any differences. There are some minor errors in the rules, but nothing major.

The play aid or summary sheet is nicely done on thick paper. I like the bloodstains. :) Good call to include the Carthaginian die legend here as well. What’s not good is that there are some errors on the summary sheet. The biggest being the Carthaginian reinforcements. Exchange one of the “1 CU with any General in Hispania (or in New Carthage) if New Carthage is Carthaginian controlled” with “1 CU with any General in Hispania (or in New Carthage) if the province of Baetica is Carthaginian controlled”.


The cards



There are two decks of cards used in Hannibal, one 64 card strategy deck and one 48 card battle deck. They are both made of coated paper of good stock. The cards are a bit smaller than the average playing card (and card sleeves) so you’ll have to get Yu-Gi-Oh sized sleeves here if you want a snug fit.

I really do recommend getting sleeves for the cards. Hannibal is a tense game so you’ll probably be all sweaty after a while which is bad for the cards. Protect those cards ASAP. I prefer clear sleeves myself, but sleeves in different colours for the two deck works as well.


Verdict

All in all I think Valley Games did great here. The game is of excellent quality and beautifully made. Ok, there are some things I would have done differently personally but that will always be the case. You simply can’t please everyone.

I rate this edition 8/10.

Note that I’m not rating the game itself (which I rate a 10) just how well made I think this edition is.
Last edited on 2007-11-12 07:25:16 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
It would be interesting to know how you rate the earlier edition.
Paul - the
flag
Avatar
0405060708
I would rate both the Avalon Hill and the Descartes edition of Hannibal about 6/10. Standard AH quality.

The production value of the VG is higher, the card stock is of better quality and the counters are much thicker but not too thick. Colour rulebook and play aid as well.
Richard Irving
flag
Avatar
Quote:
The cards are a bit smaller than the average playing card (and card sleeves) so you’ll have to get Yu-Gi-Oh sized sleeves here if you want a snug fit.


No--they aren't a bit smaller than the average playing card. Hannibal's cards are Bridge sized cards, which is one of two standard sizes for playing cards.

The other standard size are Poker sized cards.
Paul - the
flag
Avatar
0405060708
rri1 wrote:
Quote:
The cards are a bit smaller than the average playing card (and card sleeves) so you’ll have to get Yu-Gi-Oh sized sleeves here if you want a snug fit.


No--they aren't a bit smaller than the average playing card. Hannibal's cards are Bridge sized cards, which is one of two standard sizes for playing cards.

The other standard size are Poker sized cards.


Guess my old CCG roots are showing here. To me an average card is Magic sized. :)
Manuel Pombeiro
flag
Avatar
060708
Doomfarer wrote:

Guess my old CCG roots are showing here. To me an average card is Magic sized. :)


LOL and the second wide-game size are cards sized as Yo-Gi-Oh cards!! I'm with you on this even not ever been a Magic player!!
Severus Snape
flag
Avatar
050708
Quote:
I would rate both the Avalon Hill and the Descartes edition of Hannibal about 6/10. Standard AH quality.


:gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp::yuk::gulp:

People think I am hard to please, but six out of ten? Get real.

goo
Paul - the
flag
Avatar
0405060708
Ok, how would you rate them?

I can't find any huge problems with either edition myself.
Charles Féaux de la Croix
flag
Avatar
07
6/10 seems a perfectly reasonable score for the old editions. The cards aren't that nicely illustrated, for one.
Mosse Stenström
flag
Avatar
060708
Doomfarer wrote:
It’s of good quality and easy to assemble but how durable is it? Will it still hold after having been assembled 100 times?

I actually like the puzzle maps - they stay flat better and don't have that awful crease in the fold that tips counters over.

Concerning lastability I doubt very many copies of any wargame maps are ever assembled/folded 100 times. :)
Darren M
flag
Avatar
04
I'd have to agree... any game that's good enough that I play it 100 times deserves to fall apart and be replaced.
Andy Daglish
flag