geek
Rules | Subscriptions | Bookmarks | Search | Account | Moderators
Recommend
5
6 Posts
New Thread | Printer Friendly | Subscribe  | Bookmark
Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
iain watkinson
flag
Avatar
070809
Guillotine » Forums » Reviews
Games that the Family take on Holiday (Part 2)
(Part 1)
http://www.boardgamegeek.com/article/1945845#1945845

(Part 3)
http://www.boardgamegeek.com/article/1964033#1964033


As the subject suggests this is the second of a series of reviews of games that I can get the family to play while on holiday. There are many fine reviews of this game so I will focus on the family & holiday aspects.



courtesy of Ketty Galleguillos



Quick Game Overview

The object of the game is to be the champion guillotine operator over 3 days of head-cutting! You achieve this by chopping off more and better quality nobles than the other guillotine operators (players).

Components are two decks of cards - 'Action Cards' that are used to affect the line of nobles & the 'Noble Cards' (these include clergy,military,aristocrats,lackys & innocent characters caught up in the bloodshed!)

At the start of each of the 3 days 12 character cards are laid out in a line ready to get the chop.


courtesy of Luis SG


On a players turn, they can (optionally) play an action card to manipulate the order of the the line to get the highest scoring noble card(s) at the end of the line where the guillotine awaits. The player then finishes their go by taking a card from the 'Action Card' deck............and thats about it.

The fun lies in the manipulation of the line to grab the best nobles for yourself or to leave the low or minus scoring cards for the others - ha ha ;)

The action cards are not limited to line manipulation; there are also cards that will give you bonuses for collecting noble of a particular colour, as in the green characters below.


courtesy of Endor Wiggins


There are also action cards that allow you to swop/steal nobles from other players score piles & other nefarious deeds :cool:

When the last noble head is collected the day ends and twelve more victims are laid out for the guillotine; after three days you total up the points that are on the noble cards, amended as required due to action cards that have been played - good or bad, and the one with the highest points total is champion guillotine operator :)

Why this is good to take on your family holiday

It has a simple mechanic that is very easily understood by non-gamers and/or younger children.

It oozes theme, especially for children; whats not to like about chopping off the heads of the brutal ruling classes who have been living off the labour of the workers, sorry got a bit carried away there; what I meant to say was that most children are a little bit bloodthirsty.

It's portable, two decks of cards and can be played on a table in the bar/lounge/hotel room etc.

It plays quickly: typically the four of us get through the three days in about 30 to 45 minutes.

Minor Gripes

I have found that the game does not lend itself to more than 4/5 people, more than this and you don't get enough turns on each of the three days and the downtime can get to be too much, especially for younger players.

As I mentioned earlier, the heart of the game lies in the manipulation of the line. There is an action card 'Callous Guards' that when played stops the line from being altered. I STRONGLY recommend amending the text or removing this card from the game.

I have played this game with many other families who all love the theme; however it may not be to everyones tastes.


courtesy of Robert Seater


There is a character card who goes by the title 'Piss Boy', not a problem for us but could be for some families with younger children, if so, just don't play with it, its absence has minimal effect on the game.

To Finish

Take this game with you when you go on holiday. Playing this while on a family city-break to Paris was one of our all time great gaming experiences.

regards
Iain
Last edited on 2007-12-30 05:41:58 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
iain watkinson
flag
Avatar
070809
I would really welcome feedback on this review if anyone can spare the time, as I want to get better at doing them :)
Last edited on 2007-12-30 05:36:19 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
I'm now Captain Yid
flag
I agree that this is a good game to take traveling. It was the first game voted on by my family to take on our trip overseas this summer.

Some of the rules are vague and house rules have to be enforced. The Callous Guards card does let you play cards on other players. You just can't alter the line. We had one player try to reverse the line by putting the guillotine at the other end and say that the line wasn't altered, but if you put yourself in the shoes of the poor soul at the end of the line and suddenly you become first, wouldn't that be a Murphy's Law moment to an already rotten day?

There is a certain amount of conversation as to what roles each person played in the day of head recycling. My 9 year old tends to like saying "Piss Boy" more than needed, but then I did say she was nine. There is a certain amount of taunting and bragging which adds to the fun. It says for ages 12 and up, but don't underestimate the motives of a 9 year old.:arrrh:

iain watkinson
flag
Avatar
070809
Todd

Thanks for your input, much appreciated. I had a similar experience with my daughter who also found great enjoyment whenever the 'Piss Boy' card came up :D

As you rightly say, a lot of fun can be had with 'Guillotine' when getting fully into the theme of the game: we can get quite rowdy (and loud) sometimes leading to stares from other hotel guests!

Have you any suggestions for other games that perhaps you would take on holiday?

regards
iain
No. 4 son contemplates the destruction of his father's forces
flag
Avatar
0708
Iain

Thanks for the review. Would you mind saying what ages your children are? and what age you would recommend for the game? Also does it work as a 2 player?

Cheers
iain watkinson
flag
Avatar
070809
Niall

My 'children' are nearly 15 & 19 but have been playing Guillotine for at least 6 years. I would say that children as young as 7 or 8 could play & enjoy the game with as much help as may be required.

Two player is fine as each of you will get more turns at beheading the nobles, however we have had most fun with 4, 3 is also a good number.

regards
iain
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
BoardGameGeek and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.