geek
Rules | Subscriptions | Bookmarks | Search | Account | Moderators
Recommend
8
5 Posts
New Thread | Printer Friendly | Subscribe  | Bookmark
Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Erik with a K
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
070809
Poker Dice » Forums » Reviews
Taking the best elements of two games and throwing them away
Poker Dice takes the best of Poker and Yahtzee and throws them far, far away. Imagine if a Yahtzee score sheet had only 6 scoring possibilities per game. Now imagine a hand of poker where every player can only play blind bets and nothing more once the cards were dealt. Oh yeah, and the deck has all cards valued 2-8 removed. Welcome to the tiresome world of Poker Dice.


Components:
The components are quite possibly the only good part of the game. I had a set from France that came in a small round tin. Inside were 5 wooden dice with ornately designed dice showing 9, 10, J, Q, K and A.

Rules:

You roll the dice up to three times, keeping what you'd like after each roll like Yahtzee. The hands are ranked much like poker except the possibility of a 5-of-a-Kind sans Jokers. The suits are purely decorative--there are no flushes.

Possibility for Improvement
The only way I can imagine the game to be improved on is to add a second set of dice so that each player may roll simultaneously and bet after each roll, or play a Hold 'Em style where each player gets to roll two die for themselves (remained hidden from their opponent) and then roll three community die one at a time with betting between each roll.

No, scratch that. If you want to play poker, play poker. If you want to combine gambling with Yahtzee, play for a buck a game or a dime a point. Get Poker Dice for the nice-looking dice, because that's all they really have to offer.

This review is written in response to Reprint's GeekList Ranked Games without reviews ( http://www.boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/28968).
Richard Dewsbery
flag
Avatar
Re: Taking the best elements of two games and throwing them
I suspect it largely depends on what/how you play.

I was first introduced to Liars Dice by playing a very similar game using a single set of poker dice. You can roll as many or as few of the five dice as you wish, then annouce a poker hand. The next player to your left either accepts the hand, takes the dice, and tries to better it by re-rolling as many dice as he wishes (keeping any that he feels are helpful), or calls you on your throw. If you have a worse hand than you announced, you lose a life, otherwise he loses a life. Works quite well, and only requires the one set of 5 dice to pass around the table.
Rod Batten
flag
Avatar
0809
I think they used to play that bluffing game in the Sergeant's Mess using poker dice and a little wooden box. Except that it was, of course, played for drinks.

I'll have to try it out with those mysterious poker dice that have been cluttering my dice box for years.

Edit: Brun Faidetti has posted the bluffing game under "French Rules" in the rules section of the forum.

Re-edit: Here's the link: http://boardgamegeek.com/thread/292596
Last edited on 2008-06-03 13:40:19 CST (Total Number of Edits: 2)
Ask Me About the Global Geek Photo Album Project (Erik Warnes)
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
06070809
I have 2 sets of this, because a bloke at work likes it a lot. last person to win "Deals", and you have to beat their roll in as many rolls as they took or fewer. It's not bad.
The varriants you offered are pretty much close to the rules for Liar's Dice (not to be confused with Liar's Dice of the same name). Liar's Dice can be played with ordinary dice or Poker Dice (it is confusing since Poker Dice is both a component name and a game name).

In Liar's Dice, one person rolls the dice and anounces a Poker Hand. The next player can accept or challenge (similar to Liar's Dice except for the Poker Hands).

There was also a variation of Liar's Dice that was very common in Army Officer's clubs. It was a two-player game, and each person had a set of 5 dice, and a small "screen" was placed between the players so you could roll and bluff without the other seeing your hand. If you accepted the other player's bid, you could either raise as is, or roll your dice to bid.
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
BoardGameGeek and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.