geek
The Hotness
Games|People|Company
Rules | Subscriptions | Bookmarks | Search | Account | Moderators
Recommend
48
23 Posts
New Thread | Printer Friendly | Subscribe  sub options | Bookmark
Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: review [+] [View All]
Mike Burns
United Kingdom
Portsmouth
flag msg tools
mbmb
Doom: The Boardgame » Forums » Reviews
Why you should buy Doom...

What is Doom and how much does it cost?

Doom is Fantasy Flight's boardgame version of the Doom 3 PC game, for two to four players. It plays in about 2-3 hours. In England, it retails for just under £30, which is cheap for what you get. I know that our American cousins might laugh at this statement ($60 for a boardgame!!??) but unfortunately, that's the way of things in rip off England. This is probably about 2/3 of the cost of Descent, Doom's younger upstart sibling. I managed to obtain mine from Ebay for a tenner, anyway.



So what do you get for your money?

This is not a big box game, but rather the same size as Battlelore, Warrior Knights and Arkham Horror. In common with these Games, however, the box is literally packed full of components. In fact, I defy anyone to be able to shut the box properly with all of the inserts and components intact after the game has been played. These components include a wealth of futuristic dungeon floorplans (like the old GW Spacehulk ones) that fit together like jigsaw pieces; more counters and tokens than you can shake a stick at (and believe me, I can shake a stick at a lot of counters!); a deck of cards for marine special abilities and invader spawns and events and of course a wealth of sweet, sweet minis.



These deserve a paragraph all of their own. The plastic minis probably account for about half the weight of the (considerably heavy for it's size) box. There are about sixty in total, and they come in three colours (see gameplay, later).The Cyberdemon minis are about 4" tall and would make a decent paperweight. They are also well sculpted. If I had the time and artistic ability, I would love to paint my Doom minis. Unfortunately, with my artistic deficiencies, I fear the horrific invaders may well end up looking like a colourblind circus troupe...

Tell me about the gameplay!

Well, it's pretty straightforward, and it uses some rules from other dungeoncrawls. The marine players control one marine each, and the invader player controls the monsters. The amount and type of monsters scale in each scenario according to how many marines are playing - there are three marines and three different colours of monster. If a game has a red and a blue marine, only the red and blue monsters will be used, with all the green figures left in the box...

Much of Doom will be familiar to those who have played other Dungeoncrawls. The marines have a set goal (usually to exit through a specific door) and, of course, the invader's job is to stop them, usually by obtaining six frags. Frags are obtained by killing the marine players or by going through the entire invader deck. Unlike in Descent, however, there is, unfortunately no way to speed up this process.

The board develops as you play. When the marines enter a new area, the Invader player sets up the room tiles, monsters and ammo and reads a brief description of the room.

Marines have the usual choice of actions available to dungeoncrawling heroes, e.g. move/move, move/fight or fight/fight, as well as guard orders (overwatch) or specific actions such as dodge or aim. The Overlord then takes a new card and activates the monsters.

Combat is a little unusual as the dice rolled can indicate range, damage done, ammo used or a miss result - there is no combat results table. If the dice rolled are in range and no miss result is rolled, any damage over the armour rating of the target is taken off of the target's wounds. Only marines can lose ammo if an ammo icon appears on a dice face. If a marine loses all his wounds and is fragged, he is allowed to respawn next turn on a revealed space 8-16 spaces from where he died.

On the Invader player's turn, he can play spawn cards or special cards and activate his monsters, whose movement, armour, wounds, attack dice and special abilities are all listed on a handy reference card.

That's it? So what's so good about it? And why would I buy this if I already own Descent Journeys in the Dark?

Playing time. It has a shorter, more manageable playing time than Descent (2-3 hours).

The atmosphere. Doom is a game all about survival horror, with an emphasis on survival. With a good invader player, it's hard for the marines to win, and with ammo constantly being drained there can be a feeling of desperation for the marines.
It conveys a similar feeling of dread to the computer game, although I could easily see a Resident Evil conversion of the system... (drool)...

The Chrome. Doom has a ton of high quality bits, with excellent artwork and sculpts throughout.

The campaign system. It has a built in campaign system which makes sense. If the marines are lucky enough to survive until the next scenario (the game comes with six chronological scenarios) they become tougher and can take extra abilities. This is something which was not replicated in Descent...

Space Hulk. It's Space Hulk for the noughties. 'Nuff said.
Nick Bos
Denmark
Copenhagen
flag msg tools
Avatar
patron07
mbmbmbmbmb
Nice review of a great game!

Quote:
With a good invader player, it's hard for the marines to win


I agree with this statement, but it could have been more general...

With an invader player, it's hard for the marines to win would be more appropriate :p

But that's why I love the game, it's always so tight!

Thanks!

Cheers!
A I
United States

flag msg tools
Quote:
In fact, I defy anyone to be able to shut the box properly with all of the inserts and components intact after the game has been played.


I took the cardboard insert that came with the game and turned it upside-down so its more like a tray. I put all the floor tiles into the box as evenly as I can without spending too much time on it, then I put the upside-down insert on top of them, then put everything else into the insert. I fit the original game and the expansion stuff in the original box this way and it closes completely.
When unpacking just lift the insert out and you have instant access to start setting up the floor tiles and a handy tray to keep the monsters in.
Nick Bos
Denmark
Copenhagen
flag msg tools
Avatar
patron07
mbmbmbmbmb
lifepawn wrote:
Quote:
In fact, I defy anyone to be able to shut the box properly with all of the inserts and components intact after the game has been played.


I took the cardboard insert that came with the game and turned it upside-down so its more like a tray. I put all the floor tiles into the box as evenly as I can without spending too much time on it, then I put the upside-down insert on top of them, then put everything else into the insert. I fit the original game and the expansion stuff in the original box this way and it closes completely.
When unpacking just lift the insert out and you have instant access to start setting up the floor tiles and a handy tray to keep the monsters in.


Now I officially envy hate you :laugh:
If Actions Speak Louder Than Words, Then Actions x2 Speak Louder Than Actions.
United States
Hutto
Texas
flag msg tools
Avatar
patron08
mbmbmbmbmb
Sometimes I feel like playing Descent, but edgier, grittier and a bit shorter in length. There's Doom; always there as the perfect alternative.

Also, some people you know just won't be able to wrap their brains around Descent at first go. That's when I bring out my Descent-trainer, Doom, to get them up to speed.

Great review!
Mike Holyoak
United States
Idaho Falls
Idaho
flag msg tools
Avatar
patron070809
mbmbmbmbmb
Not to mention that with the awesome expansion, you get rules, tokens, and maps for Death Match mode and Capture the Flag mode, which are even faster than campaign mode and can be just as fun!:devil:
Sneaker
Greece
Athens
flag msg tools
Avatar
patron08
mbmbmbmbmb
Romeo wrote:
If the dice rolled are in range and no miss result is rolled, any damage over the armour rating of the target is taken off of the target's wounds.


Actually this is what happens in Descent, not in this game. In DOOM you divide the damage rolled by the marine's armour and you apply that many wounds rounded down. So, if for example you roll 7 damage and the marine has 2 armour, he takes 3 wounds( 7/2=3.5 => 3 ) NOT 5 (7-2=5). (You can check page 8 of the manual)

Thus, the difference between 2 armour and 3 armour is HUGE...

Apart from that detail this is a very nice review! Indeed, DOOM is a great game and it has given me and my group countless hours of fun!
Rob Buchler
United States

Michigan
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmb
Just got this game this week for $34 from ThoughtHammer -- it was a ding and dent due to a barely noticeable tear from a corner being smunched a tad.
Just opened the box this evening and right now am drying the 12 or so figures that had slight base warping that I dunked in near-boiling water. The bases are nice and flat now.

The only figures I'm not too keen on are the three Marine figures. I thought they would be a little beefier and more dynamically posed. But the big figures are impressive and scream out to be painted.

The cardboard components are excellently done. The two card decks are a bit thin but don't look to be a problem.

Am looking forward to trying the game out -- nice review! And even if I end up just using the figures for other sci-fi gaming (assuming they get painted), I figure I've got a lot of bang for my $34 bucks.
Last edited on 2008-03-13 19:35:47 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
Sean Neuerburg
United States
Hammond
Louisiana
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Romeo wrote:
The campaign system. It has a built in campaign system which makes sense. If the marines are lucky enough to survive until the next scenario (the game comes with six chronological scenarios) they become tougher and can take extra abilities. This is something which was not replicated in Descent...

...but will be surpassed by Descent: The Road to Legend.
Wes Nott
United States
Warrensburg
Missouri
flag msg tools
mbmb
logopolys wrote:
Romeo wrote:
The campaign system. It has a built in campaign system which makes sense. If the marines are lucky enough to survive until the next scenario (the game comes with six chronological scenarios) they become tougher and can take extra abilities. This is something which was not replicated in Descent...

...but will be surpassed by Descent: The Road to Legend.


It's too bad FFG won't do one "last hurrah" for the Doom Boardgame. I wonder if it just isn't a big seller or perhaps it is a licensing issue?
Brian M
United States
Thornton
Colorado
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
The campaign system has its issues. While your wounds carry over, your remaining frags don't matter. Therefore, if you have a badly wounded marine but have frags left, its better to get killed and respawn at full health. And, if the marines actually do well at a mission or two and manage to buy some good upgrades, they can become pretty unstoppable.

I think the 2 hour min time estimate is going to be low for any game where the marines don't get slaughtered in the first room or two.

Slow paced game, balance scales badly with number of players, offers frustration and a slow plodding feel instead of tension and excitement, dull for the Invader player...ugh. Skip it and track down a copy of Space Hulk, Siege of the Citadel or Aliens.
General Protection Fault
Canada
Winnipeg
Manitoba
flag msg tools
Avatar
patron05060709
logopolys wrote:
Romeo wrote:
The campaign system. It has a built in campaign system which makes sense. If the marines are lucky enough to survive until the next scenario (the game comes with six chronological scenarios) they become tougher and can take extra abilities. This is something which was not replicated in Descent...

...but will be surpassed by Descent: The Road to Legend.

I've got to hand it to FFG's marketing! They've got people convinced their product is the best and deprecates all competition (even their own products) before it's even released.

Reminds me of a company in Redmond, WA.
Last edited on 2008-03-14 13:43:07 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
Andrew Carlstrom
United States
San Marcos
California
flag msg tools
Avatar
patron06070809
mbmbmbmbmb
Doom is a great game and in some ways better than Descent. It certainly is easier to teach, as the core mechanics remain but much of Decent's chrome is removed. If works much better for my 7 and 5 year olds.
F H
United Kingdom

UK
flag msg tools
designer
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
I love this game. It Plays very well. I dont understand people having speed issues with it? When I play with the guys at work its always engaging and a darn good time.

Of course the marines have only ever had a partial win ( 2 got out 1 didnt ), but thats what makes it so good.
Adam
Canada
Winnipeg
Manitoba
flag msg tools
Avatar
patron050607
mbmb
generalpf wrote:
I've got to hand it to FFG's marketing! They've got people convinced their product is the best and deprecates all competition (even their own products) before it's even released.

Reminds me of a company in Redmond, WA.


Microsoft, Nintendo or both?
Christopher Marx
United States
Tarpon Springs
Florida
flag msg tools
patron0506
mbmbmbmb
generalpf wrote:
logopolys wrote:
Romeo wrote:
The campaign system. It has a built in campaign system which makes sense. If the marines are lucky enough to survive until the next scenario (the game comes with six chronological scenarios) they become tougher and can take extra abilities. This is something which was not replicated in Descent...

...but will be surpassed by Descent: The Road to Legend.

I've got to hand it to FFG's marketing! They've got people convinced their product is the best and deprecates all competition (even their own products) before it's even released.

Reminds me of a company in Redmond, WA.


The complete rules were posted days ago.
Randolph Bookman
United States
Los Angeles
California
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
I highly recommend the expansion. It fixes the problems that people have with the stand alone game adds some cool new baddies and 6 players.
General Protection Fault
Canada
Winnipeg
Manitoba
flag msg tools
Avatar
patron05060709
crumbb wrote:
generalpf wrote:
logopolys wrote:
Romeo wrote:
The campaign system. It has a built in campaign system which makes sense. If the marines are lucky enough to survive until the next scenario (the game comes with six chronological scenarios) they become tougher and can take extra abilities. This is something which was not replicated in Descent...

...but will be surpassed by Descent: The Road to Legend.

I've got to hand it to FFG's marketing! They've got people convinced their product is the best and deprecates all competition (even their own products) before it's even released.

Reminds me of a company in Redmond, WA.

The complete rules were posted days ago.

But the astroturfing starting weeks ago.
Chris Franka
United States
San Antonio
Texas
flag msg tools
Avatar
patron0708
mbmbmbmbmb
Lagduf wrote:
logopolys wrote:
Romeo wrote:
The campaign system. It has a built in campaign system which makes sense. If the marines are lucky enough to survive until the next scenario (the game comes with six chronological scenarios) they become tougher and can take extra abilities. This is something which was not replicated in Descent...

...but will be surpassed by Descent: The Road to Legend.


It's too bad FFG won't do one "last hurrah" for the Doom Boardgame. I wonder if it just isn't a big seller or perhaps it is a licensing issue?


I've heard that Kevin finished another expansion, but that FFG wouldn't commit to printing it. Second hand information from someone who talked to him at a con, but I have no real reason to distrust him. Don't know why FFG wouldn't go with it--I'm sure it's $$$.
Steffen Beck
Germany
Unterföhring
flag msg tools
mb
you got me sold! :)

was really looking into buying DESCENT, but i guess that stems from some strange HERO QUEST nostalgia...i might have to buy both, but now i just might go with DOOM to start with...thanks!-
Last edited on 2008-04-08 08:56:17 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
Mike Hill


msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmb
Yeah. I picked DOOM up at the NYComicCon yestarday from the troll and toad booth which was, incidentally, right next to the FFG booth. I laughed when i saw Descent for $80 in the FFG booth and the same game for $60 about 10 ft away. Anywho I havent played it yet but I think you made a good desision getting DOOM, I heard talk that the length of Descent makes it drag, and the amount of equiptment you get is overwhelming, whereas you dont have your sword for very long until you get another. Im very satisfied of what ive seen of DOOM so far, and it looks solid. I just wish there were more scenarios. if anyone has a link to a place with more scenarios do tell.
Andre Tsurukame
United States
Lomita
California
flag msg tools
To answer the poster asking about more scenarios, I found this link for a site that collects new player-made scenarios (and game supplements):
http://www.doom-tbg.net/

I was crusing the archived Doom forum on the fantasy flight forum and found a post about more scenarios available there. I haven't downloading any and don't know how much overlap there is with the file list for doom here on BGG.

Also in case you didn't know, FFG posted an official standalone scenario online, Blood in the Shadows, available on this page:
http://www.fantasyflightgames.com/doomsupport.html

FYI - archived Doom forum on FFG - some good info and tips there:
http://www.fantasyflightgames.com/cgi-bin/yabb/YaBB.cgi?boar...

Current Doom forum on FFG - it's newer so it doesn't have has many posts but it is still active.
http://www.fantasyflightgames.com/ffgforums/forums/show/16.p...
Mike Hill


msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmb
thanks alot. Iv done some looking, and apparently the scenario question is one that is well asked here, by alot of people.
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
BoardGameGeek and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.