geek
Recently Viewed
Hot Games
Agricola
Battlestar Galactica
Race for the Galaxy
Conflict of Heroes: Awakening the Bear! - Russia 1941-1942
A Touch of Evil, The Supernatural Game
End of the Triumvirate, The
Puerto Rico
Arkham Horror
Settlers of Catan, The
Axis & Allies Anniversary Edition
Dominion
Stone Age
Pandemic
Wabash Cannonball
Scepter of Zavandor, The
Age of Conan - The BoardGame
Power Grid
Twilight Struggle
BattleLore
Agricola Z-Deck
Carcassonne
Risk
StarCraft: The Board Game
Tomb
War of the Ring
Through the Ages: A Story of Civilization
Reiner Knizia's Decathlon
Race for the Galaxy: The Gathering Storm
Last Night on Earth: The Zombie Game
Tigris & Euphrates
Descent: Journeys in the Dark
Die Macher
Batavia
Age of Empires III: The Age of Discovery
El Grande
Titan
Twilight Imperium 3rd Edition
Galactic Emperor
Ticket to Ride
Witch's Brew
Kingsburg
Jamaica
Caylus
Descent: Tomb of Ice
New World: A Carcassonne Game
World of Warcraft: the Adventure Game
Memoir '44
Arkham Horror - The Black Goat of the Woods Expansion
Brass
Shogun
Rules | Subscriptions | Bookmarks | Search | Account | Moderators
Recommend
89
34 Posts
1 , 2  Next »  
New Thread | Printer Friendly | Subscribe | Bookmark
Your Tags: Login to Add Tags | View 
Popular Tags: [View All]
Shane Walsh
flag

This is my first shot at a review and because of the format I have chosen to use it may very well all end in tears if my "review" is shot down in flames ...
Anyway , here goes ...

There seems to be a fair number of excellent reviews and session reports which deal with the rules , gameplay and mechanics with regard to this game . Hopefully my "review" will help you to decide whether you should bother to save the world from virulent disease or not ..

6 Reasons To Buy Pandemic :

]
1) Thematically It's Strong : With outbreaks of disease and epidemics occurring - players striving in the roles as Medics , Scientists , Researchers and the like to find a cure and stop the spread of the infectious diseases (i.e.cubes)it does have strong elements of saving the world from apocalyptic disaster . Give the coloured cubes a name (i.e. Ebola Virus , A.I.D.S., Avian Bird Flu and Mad Cow Disease) like we have and it's even more thematic .

2) Replayability : Start game setup means that each scenario is different - the roles the players receive mesh in different ways meaning each game requires different tactics - the initial spread of diseased cities requires a differing plan - and the appearance of cards throughout the game skews gameplay significantly each time . Add the option of playing with fewer players (easier) or more "Epidemic" cards (harder) and you can make this as (relatively - but not very easy) or as devilishly difficult as you like .

3) It Scratches A Little Scratched Itch : There are a number of co-operative games out there and in truth I cannot comment on them as I have not played any of these . Suffice to say that my impression from my time at BGG is that this a category which could always do with more options . Pandemic delivers . Getting the table talk and group think thing going is a wonderfully different and refreshing slant to gaming . I love competitive gaming but this is a delightful and satisfying itch to scratch too .

4) Family Gaming Is Fun : I have a wife and 2 children aged 12 and 9 and this has been a hit - the 9 year-old generally takes one of the easier roles (Medic or Operations Expert)and again the sense of co-operation involved just sits oh so well with a mad gaming father who wants to integrate board gaming into as many aspects of family fun times as he can ! Again , in this respect , Pandemic delivers .

5) Time Is Of The Essence : You soon realize that this is true as you play the game - thus providing one of it's delicious challenges - but it is also true literally because the game (give or take 10 minutes or so) rarely takes more than an hour .

6) Theatre And Tension : Like the plot of an intriguing novel there are twists and turns , moments of tension and in most games a buildup of events to the endgame where you all win OR all lose . I've played around 15 games now and whilst we have had our head handed to us on a platter on some occasions and also had a (relatively comfortable) victory in a few -most games are "down to the wire" affairs where just one more move/card/action may have been enough to save us all . Theatre - yes as the plot thickens . Tension - definetly !

6 Reasons Not To Buy Pandemic :

1) Beware The Significant Other : This game CAN be hijacked if you or your spouse/relative/gamer friend is strongly opinionated . Groupthink is a plus here but it can be destroyed by someone who has a tendency to ride roughshod over others .

2) It's A Small World After All : Well the board is - anyway . At game setup and when there are many diseased cities in a small area the board can be crowded and difficult to examine . Sorry but this a design flaw that could have been easily avoided .

3) Err ...

4) Ummm ...

5) Ahhhh ...

6) It's Time Consuming : That's because one game soon is followed by another and another and ...


So , should you splash out on Pandemic ? Maybe I'm not to be trusted because I've been well and truly infected ...!!!
Last edited on 2008-07-04 00:43:39 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
Brad N
flag
Avatar
0708
Nice review. Personally, I like your format as I am usually looking for those things that the reviewer likes and dislikes about the game. And, you just get straight to the point in that regard. I now own Pandemic too and agree with your comments on the game. This one is very good!
Shane Walsh
flag
bnordeng wrote:
Nice review. Personally, I like your format as I am usually looking for those things that the reviewer likes and dislikes about the game. And, you just get straight to the point in that regard. I now own Pandemic too and agree with your comments on the game. This one is very good!


Thanks for your kind words Brad for my first review - you will love Pandemic , I'm sure .

I may also be persuaded to submit more 5/6/7/8 Reasons To / Not To Buy a "Certain Game" ...

Would this be a worthwhile exercise ?? ....
Seiya V
flag
Avatar
I liked the format of your review, and I think it would be great if you also included more about what you don't like about pandemic. :laugh:

I know 3-6 were intended to be a joke (and honestly its hard to find negative things to say about this game) but it does make it one sided for people who have never played the game.
Shane Walsh
flag
seiyaaa wrote:
I liked the format of your review, and I think it would be great if you also included more about what you don't like about pandemic. :laugh:

I know 3-6 were intended to be a joke (and honestly its hard to find negative things to say about this game) but it does make it one sided for people who have never played the game.


Thanks for your kind words but as you accurately said it IS hard to find negative points with Pandemic .

Yes , points 3 to 6 were meant to be lighthearted but for me this how I see this clever game - 6 positives balanced by 2 negatives . I will write similiar reviews on other games and they will have less/more positives and/or negatives dependent on how I perceive those games to be from my unique(misguided/twisted perspective)!!!
Nicolas Guay
flag
Avatar
07
I liked your review format as well as the humour in it

Well done,
Nick
Brad N
flag
Avatar
0708
6 seems like a good number and I'm not sure the "how many" reasons is important as long as you have included the information you think will be valuable to others. So, 5/6/7/8 would be okay as far as I'm concerned. Being concise yet fairly complete is a challenge, but I think you did it well with this one.

One minor not on formatting is that I think it might be easier to scan and read if you bolded the lines that read "6 Reasons To Buy Pandemic :" and "6 Reasons Not To Buy Pandemic :". Just a thought.
Blake Phillips
flag
Avatar
Well done - appreciate the time effort you put into this review. I don't always enjoy a rules rehash though it can be useful. I think in this case it was not needed. I agree with the map size problem that you mentioned but I think the problem is not the map so much as the over sized pawns and research facilities. I don't mind the cube size - when they get stacked up it just adds to the delicious tension that you mentioned in your review. But I think research facilities and pawns of 1/2 the size would have been better. Like this:


Photo by Miguel Marques

This is my only gripe though and it is MINOR. I have played this game 15 times in the last week. Last night my wife and I played 2 games - we actually won on the easy level... she was done but I was not... so I played two more at the regular level - solo - with 3 characters. Besides Up Front, which I have just discovered in the last month, I have not had this much fun since I first broke out Battlelore.
Last edited on 2008-07-03 12:43:08 CST (Total Number of Edits: 5)
Francis K. Lalumiere
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
0708
Nice review. And I like the format just fine: I'm one of those who don't think a review should include a cut & paste of the entire rulebook.
So thanks!
Ice Hensley
flag
Quote:
6) It's Time Consuming : That's because one game soon is followed by another and another and ...


Most definitely. We haven't been able to play just one game yet.
Jeff Block
flag
Avatar
Yaboo wrote:
Well done - appreciate the time effort you put into this review. I don't always enjoy a rules rehash though it can be useful. I think in this case it was not needed. I agree with the map size problem that you mentioned but I think the problem is not the map so much as the over sized pawns and research facilities. I don't mind the cube size - when they get stacked up it just adds to the delicious tension that you mentioned in your review. But I think research facilities and pawns of 1/2 the size would have been better. Like this:


Photo by Miguel Marques


That's fantastic! Where did you get the smaller pieces?

Although I've read arguments about how the big pawns are preferred, the research stations are waaaay too big for their usefulness (magnified when the city is infected).
Barry Roy
flag
Unfortunately, the people who I play games with (wife and sons) do not abide lengthy rules explanations. Literally, the game must be playable upon opening. Does this fit that criteria? I hope so, I really want to get it.
Darren Dolder
flag
Don't worry Barry. I found everything very well explained in the rules and apart from a little blip with the "share knowledge" action have never had any problems at all.

As it plays very well solo, this is a game you can play a couple of times yourself, so that you are really comfortable when introducing it to new players.

If you can actually find anywhere that has a copy , just buy it. A really good cooperative game.
Peter Hansell
flag
Game Designer
Game Publisher