geek
Recently Viewed
Hot Games
Dominion
Agricola
Android
Settlers of Catan, The
Axis & Allies Anniversary Edition
Battlestar Galactica
Race for the Galaxy
Pandemic
Titan
Puerto Rico
Wasabi!
Le Havre
Apples to Apples
Power Grid
Ghost Stories
Carcassonne
Twilight Struggle
Arkham Horror
Conflict of Heroes: Awakening the Bear! - Russia 1941-1942
Ticket to Ride
Through the Ages: A Story of Civilization
Tigris & Euphrates
Risk
War of the Ring
Descent: Journeys in the Dark
Stone Age
Formula D
Lost Cities: The Board Game
Last Night on Earth: The Zombie Game
Caylus
StarCraft: The Board Game
BattleLore
Twilight Imperium 3rd Edition
Red November
El Grande
Space Alert
Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage
Galaxy Trucker
Race for the Galaxy: The Gathering Storm
Mad Gab
Age of Empires III: The Age of Discovery
Scrabble
Hive
Munchkin Quest
A Touch of Evil, The Supernatural Game
Sequence
Guess Who
World of WarCraft Miniatures Game
Clue
Railroad Tycoon
Rules | Subscriptions | Bookmarks | Search | Account | Moderators
Recommend
26
5 Posts
New Thread | Printer Friendly | Subscribe | Bookmark
Your Tags: Login to Add Tags | View 
Popular Tags: [View All]
Tom Vasel
flag
Avatar
0405060708
When one designer continues to design games in the same series, it's a neat thing to watch; as the games get better and better. I'm in the camp that Railroad Tycoon took the great game Age of Steam and made it more accessible to most folks, adding in great components and more fun. Railroad Tycoon wasn't perfect, but I still wanted to see some expansions for it - especially as Age of Steam seems to be the most expansion-oriented game ever. Finally, Rails of Europe (Eagle Games, 2008 - Glenn Drover) has been released, which is technically an expansion for Railroad Tycoon but can almost be called a slight upgrade as well.

Rails of Europe does an excellent job at tightening up the board a bit (as well as the obvious fact that the map changes to Europe) and adds a few other changes that make it slightly superior to the original game. I can play either game and be satisfied, but I certainly prefer the European version. Rails over Europe is hopefully the first expansion in a line of games that takes the Railroad Tycoon system and improves and expands it.

So what's in the expansion?

- The map is Europe, a noticeable change from the original game map, which was the Eastern section of the United States of America. More importantly, the board is about 2/3 the size of the original board, which while still covering a large amount of the table is slightly easier to manage. The board is also a single piece (less shifting!), although it still folds inward with those annoying little "valleys" that it creates. Extra space is included on the scoring track, making it easier to move the scoring pieces around. There's a lot less wasted space on the board (although Great Britain is sadly ignored). The board is a little clearer with regard to colors, as it is easier to tell blue and purple hexes apart. At the same time, in poor lighting, the blue and black hexes can be occasionally confused. The map has much less of a sprawl than the previous one did, and there is no "high income" zone, like the far northeast in the first map. Everything is evenly spread out, with more mountains, and fewer connections.
- Railroad Barons are dealt to each player (the same as the original game), but this time players are dealt two and can choose between them. While they are very similar to the original Tycoons (points for the most links, the most consecutive links, etc.), having the choice is nice - especially if one of the Barons is a play style you don't wish to use. If you don't like either one, well, that's tough luck; but one of them should be interesting and possibly enough to build a strategy around.
- Major Rail Lines are handled completely differently than in the original game. Instead of players waiting until a specific Railroad Operation card is turned over, they can complete any of the five major lines (all listed on six convenient Major Line cards). Players simply have to connect the two cities on the cards (not an easy task) to score the points. Since players can start attempting to connect the cities from turn one, this (along with the Baron cards) helps determine a player's strategy.
- The game comes with twenty-nine new Railroad Operation cards, which take the place of the original deck. Many of these are very similar to the original cards with a few interesting additions. City Charters choose a city (a smaller one), and the player who takes that card is the only player who may build a link into that city. As you can imagine, if these cards show up early in the game, the demand (especially in a five player game) is quite high. Capital Charters are similar to hotels, except that they give a player one point for every link built into a particular city. These are extremely powerful, which is why they are limited to only one per player. At the same time, they allow for some interesting player interactions, as other players may deliberately build tracks in such a way as to limit the number of connections into a city. Tunnel Engineer cards cut the price of a future build in half for mountains and ridges. Considering how many mountains are on the map, this card is also quickly snapped up when it appears.
- Interestingly, the rules about "following" rivers are no longer in place. Instead, if a hex has any water at all, it's a water hex. This makes the game simpler, I suppose; but we still play with the rules from the original edition.

Players will need the money (if you haven't replaced it with superior poker chips), trains, tiles, and other physical pieces from the original game; and everything fits fairly well into the original box, although I have no idea how future expansions will fit.

The rules are fairly simple and short, although a few things could have been made clearer. For example, the rules about major lines are under the "Strategy" section, which could easily be missed by folks who don't want to read that section. Teaching the game is simple; it's the same thing as Railroad Tycoon - most changes are minor. Regardless, the game feels like a much-polished version of the original game. While I enjoy Railroad Tycoon quite a bit (it's knocked Age of Steam rather far down my list of enjoyable games), I think I prefer this version.

If I want to play a wide, sprawling game, with six players (since the expansion only covers up to five), then the original game is what I'm looking for. However, a tighter, faster, different animal emerges with the new map (twenty-six fewer cities), and the major links and simplified rules go a far way into making this expansion practically Railroad Tycoon 1.2. Fans of the original will easily enjoy the expansion; and hopefully, it's the first in a long line of expansions to come.

Tom Vasel
"Real men play board games"
www.thedicetower.com
Matthew Watson
flag
Nice review. :)

Now I'm REALLY annoyed I didn't pick this up when I had the opportunity!
Bill Morgal
flag
Avatar
0708
Thanks for the great review. I hope this helps RT gain in popularity. I think it is unfairly dismissed by some. RoE improves a great game and makes it greater. They are both amongst my favorite games and I also hope there are more expansions in store. Rails of Britain? Rails of the Old West?
Leo Shead
flag
Nice review. The main issue that we have found with Rails of Europe is that there is far more conflict than the original game, due to less space on the board. I play with non-aggressive players who like to do their own thing and avoid everyone else, which is possible with the original game (unless you're in the North-East), but much more difficult with the new version.

I think that the smaller board is much better, as we have very seldom had a table that can accommodate the original board, and with overhanging someone inevitably jogs the table and chaos results. City and capital charters have not been that popular so far (the city charters are all for grey cities), apart from the strategy to keep putting new cubes on the chartered city, which sometimes works well.

I will say that when I buy an expansion I like things to add to the original game, and not replace. Potential buyers should be aware that the "expansion" is really a "replacement". However, it does add some longevity to RT.
Ian Madsen
flag
Avatar
0708
Myrdin T Sasnak wrote:
Thanks for the great review. I hope this helps RT gain in popularity. I think it is unfairly dismissed by some. RoE improves a great game and makes it greater. They are both amongst my favorite games and I also hope there are more expansions in store. Rails of Britain? Rails of the Old West?
I can't find the thread now, but I had read something about how they were planning on reprinting the RRT base game, but with a map of Mexico, and release an improved US map as an expansion. It sounded like they were going to print the Mexico map on paper rather then a board (like most wargames) to reduce the cost.

Edit (found the thread): http://boardgamegeek.com/thread/325102
Last edited on 2008-08-12 12:27:30 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
 
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
BoardGameGeek and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.