geek
We're trying to reach 3000 New Supporters by the end of 2008!
BoardGameGeek Supporter Drive
300 600 900 1200 1500 1800 2100 2400 2700 3000 3300
   
711 New Supporters - Support BGG Now!
Recently Viewed
Hot Games
Dominion
Agricola
Battlestar Galactica
Axis & Allies Anniversary Edition
Android
Lost Cities: The Board Game
Pandemic
Settlers of Catan, The
Sorry! Sliders
Race for the Galaxy
Le Havre
Puerto Rico
Colosseum
Wasabi!
Power Grid
Ghost Stories
Carcassonne
Arkham Horror
Through the Ages: A Story of Civilization
Conflict of Heroes: Awakening the Bear! - Russia 1941-1942
Ticket to Ride
Twilight Struggle
Apples to Apples
War of the Ring
Titan
BattleLore
Stone Age
Tigris & Euphrates
Owner's Choice
Descent: Journeys in the Dark
Red November
Age of Conan: The Strategy Board Game
Last Night on Earth: The Zombie Game
Risk
Race for the Galaxy: The Gathering Storm
Scrabble
Caylus
Twilight Imperium 3rd Edition
Galaxy Trucker
Space Alert
Formula D
A Touch of Evil, The Supernatural Game
Munchkin Quest
Age of Empires III: The Age of Discovery
El Grande
Memoir '44
Mad Gab
Shadows over Camelot
StarCraft: The Board Game
Guess Who
Rules | Subscriptions | Bookmarks | Search | Account | Moderators
Recommend
2
Carl
flag
Avatar
Revolution seems to be an ideal game to play by email b/c it is a perfect information game with no dice or cards and it would be fairly simple to just send a file with the game map to the opponents as the game progresses. However there doesn't seem to be a Vassal module for it and I'm not able to make one as I don't have that expertise.
Have others played Revolution by email in other ways? Does it work well and easily?
Feedback on this would be appreciated!
Brad Miller
flag
Avatar
0405060708
I have a kind of sloppy cyberboard gamebox that I made for Revolution.

Tried to run a game once. Went on for nearly a year before players stopped responding. The province resolution requires a ridiculously convoluted process or else you are waiting on players to act forever...

Too many emails are neccessary.

That being said, I'm going to try and start another one soon :what:
Geoffrey Engelstein
flag
Avatar
0405060708
I was in that game -- and it did indeed drag. We also had some rules issues that probably should have been ironed out prior to starting.

But if someone is starting a new one I could be talked into it...

Geoff
Carl
flag
Avatar
Why would province conflict resolution take so many emails? After each faction has placed their new units, then you just get one person or a game master to reduce the number of units in each overfilled province by one per faction until you're done.
I'd be interested in trying it by email after i brush up on the rules again first. I have to warn you that I'm a newbie but I'd love to play and learn the game better. So it looks like we have three people already ... Could I see that cyberboard module, Brad?
Last edited on 2008-10-01 08:21:56 CST (Total Number of Edits: 2)
Bas Luijten
flag
Avatar
0708
Interesting...

Scurvodsky wrote:
I have to warn you that I'm a newbie but I'd love to play and learn the game better. So it looks like we have three people already ...


Same here. Four.
Carl
flag
Avatar
I just got an email from someone else who would like to join a pbem game. So it looks like we have 5 people!

Now we would just need to work out the logistics of how to do this. The cyberboard module seems like the best option unless anyone has any other ideas.
Bas Luijten
flag
Avatar
0708
No problems with a newbie? Never played any game by email; played 2/3 of a Revolution game a long time ago.
Carl
flag
Avatar
Quote:
No problems with a newbie? Never played any game by email; played 2/3 of a Revolution game a long time ago.


Not as far as I'm concerned. I'm a newbie as well. PBEM has the advantage of making it easy to consult rules as you go along if you're unsure of things. We'll have to wait to hear from the others to see if this will fly. Thanks for your interest!
Steve Bachman
flag
050608
Scurvodsky wrote:
Why would province conflict resolution take so many emails? After each faction has placed their new units, then you just get one person or a game master to reduce the number of units in each overfilled province by one per faction until you're done.
I'd be interested in trying it by email after i brush up on the rules again first. I have to warn you that I'm a newbie but I'd love to play and learn the game better. So it looks like we have three people already ... Could I see that cyberboard module, Brad?

Brad was referring not to Conflict, but to Intraprovince movement. IIRC, they were trying to do it one province at a time which probably close to doubles the length of time required for the game as a whole. I think it would work fine if instead, it was dealt with faction at a time as much as possible. Quite often, one faction has only majorities to deal with in most of the provinces they are present in. They go first and take care of all of the provinces that they can. The next faction that can do a bulk of their movements would then go and so on. By the end, in a full 5-player game, there should likely be at most 2 move files per faction to resolve the entire phase. If you don't use an efficient method here, it will likely cause the dragging that collapsed earlier attempts.

I've played a complete game of Revolution PBeM in about 4 months. It was a 2-player game, which helps a little bit, but even a full game shouldn't take more than 6-8 months. The Cyberboard could be used if needed, but the game can be tracked in a spreadsheet to speed play. Rather than having everyone have to create move files for every little thing, it might go quicker to use a spreadsheet to track it and post actions for others to follow along (either with a real board, Cyberboard, or spreadsheet as well). Updated screenshots at significant points would keep everyone on the same page too.

If you play it PBeM, I encourage you to use Brad's Yahoo! group so that others can follow along.
Brad Miller
flag
Avatar
0405060708
Scurvodsky wrote:
Could I see that cyberboard module, Brad?


In the links section there is a yahoo group link. In that group's files section is my, (and someone else's as well), gamebox.
Carl
flag
Avatar
Thanks, Brad. I see that there is your gamebox and also lateegyptian's gamebox. Which one is better/easier to use? I don't have any experience with cyberboard. What would you advise, Brad? You indicated above that you'd be interested in starting another email game. Would now be the time? Could everyone perhaps confirm that they would like to participate in this so that we could get the ball rolling?
Brad Miller
flag
Avatar
0405060708
I've never opened the other one, so I can't comment.

And if you or one of the other people want to start a game, please feel free :D

I'm not currently ready to take that on.
Carl