geek
Recently Viewed
Hot Games
Agricola
Dominion
Battlestar Galactica
Settlers of Catan, The
Android
Pandemic
Arkham Horror
Race for the Galaxy
War of the Ring
Le Havre
Carcassonne
Power Grid
Puerto Rico
Axis & Allies Anniversary Edition
Cosmic Encounter
Ghost Stories
Twilight Struggle
Through the Ages: A Story of Civilization
Conflict of Heroes: Awakening the Bear! - Russia 1941-1942
Descent: Journeys in the Dark
StarCraft: The Board Game
Tigris & Euphrates
Stone Age
Combat Commander: Pacific
Apples to Apples
Ticket to Ride
Risk
Talisman 4th Edition
Caylus
Space Alert
Memoir '44
Last Night on Earth: The Zombie Game
Galaxy Trucker
Twilight Imperium 3rd Edition
Brass
StarCraft: Brood War
Lost Cities: The Board Game
BattleLore
El Grande
Bang!
Wasabi!
Shogun
Citadels
Railroad Tycoon
Race for the Galaxy: The Gathering Storm
Clue
Formula D
Acquire
Combat Commander: Europe
Tide of Iron
Rules | Subscriptions | Bookmarks | Search | Account | Moderators
Matt Drake
flag
Avatar
0708
Let's assume you just read the title of this game and weren't offended right off the bat. Maybe you said, 'you know, I'm not really sure what that's about, maybe it won't be as bad as it sounds.' If that's what you said, I hate to tell you this, but you're about to be disappointed.

Playing Gods isn't just accidentally or mildly offensive. Each player takes on the role of a deity trying to obliterate all the others gods by recruiting or decimating their followers. Buddha carries a chain gun. Allah carries a bomb. And the most offensive of all of these gods is Jesus, who is swinging a giant cross with a spike in the crossbar. In fact, I think it's just a contest at this point to see who blows up Balls Out Entertainment first - crazed Muslims or rabid Christians. My money is on the Muslims. They were going to bomb that Danish newspaper just for a bunch of cartoons. An actual statue of Allah carrying a bomb has got to put them over the top.

[AFTER THE FACT EDIT: The creator of Playing Gods pointed out to me that he never actually mentions that the guy with the bomb is Allah or Mohammed. So if you're a foaming-at-the-mouth Islamic terrorist, you can put away the vest full of C4 - the guy is not making images of your favorite deity. But if you were considering it, feel free to put the vest back on and pull the trigger anyway - just do it someplace where nobody useful will get hurt, like at an anti-gay-marriage rally.]

But even thought it is horribly offensive to nearly anyone religious, Playing Gods is also really funny. For instance, there are five gods that come with the game, and a sixth generic god with a couple blank spots. The sheet of stickers in the box lets you customize that sixth god for whatever you think people will worship - Scientology (represented by a picture of Tom Cruise), Jehovah's Witnesses (with a picture of a finger ringing a doorbell), and Oprah (with a picture of Oprah). Yeah, it's offensive, but it's damned funny.

The game involves rolling a die, moving your god around the aetheric pathway around the world, and using cards to try to kill or convert the sects of the other gods. It's actually pretty straight-forward - you move, and then you interact with the space you land on. If you land on some spaces, you draw a card. Some spaces are portals that let you affect the religious sects on the planet below. And a few do special weird stuff, like jump to another space or steal cards from the other people.

The real fun comes when you get to ruin your opponent's followers with acts of gods (yes, it's lower-case - there are a bunch of different gods in this game, and every one causes earthquakes, mudslides and tidal waves). You play the wrath cards you've run around collecting, and then you watch sects devoted to the other gods fall into the ocean or go up in smoke.

If you want to be a little less aggressive, you can also convert your opponent's sects. There are conversion cards you can play like resurrection and miracles, and then the other god can play cards like prosperity and afterlife, and the god who plays more cards wins. The trick here is that if a god can later come through and kill some of those converted dudes, they'll revert back to their original faith. So there are times when it's handy to kill, and times when it's great to recruit. All things considered, this part is pretty damned fun.

The problem comes in when you try to find the strategy in the game, because there really isn't very much to be had. The die rolls determine what you can do on any given turn, and so you may wind up sitting on a portal to a continent where you're the only god with any followers, and then you do whatever gods do when they're boreed (I don't know what they do. Kill something? Not sure). And to really crank up the luck factor, there's a card called Godkiller, and if you land on the space while holding the Godkiller card, you just point to the player who is winning the game and go, 'sorry, you lose.' It's the most arbitrary player elimination I've ever seen... but it's hilarious.

So the game is a little like Candyland for people who want the express train to Hell. So you can get kicked out of the game with no control over the process whatsoever. So it's offensive, and violent, and twisted. It's side-splitting fun, and I don't care if it has anything in common with chess, because I had a blast playing it. Hell, we had so much fun, we played it twice, even though one player got Godkilled in both games (that's what he gets for trying to win!)

I think the greatest thing about Playing Gods is the point it makes. If you are offended by the concept of this game, you need to lighten the hell up. It's a joke, for God's sake (yeah, I did that on purpose). It's humor and great satire. It points out incredible inconsistencies in the religions we hold most dear (OK, not me, but you might. I'm probably about to be buried in the next mudslide for my personal opinions regarding world religions). It points out how retarded it is to go to war over something as petty as a religious difference. And it makes you laugh the whole time.

As everyone who plays board games knows, no game is complete unless it has expansions. Playing Gods is no exception. The expansion in this case is another little batch of cards you can add to the wrath cards that let you just grab up extra followers (by doing stuff like banning birth control - more Christian sects - or declaring an open-ended war on terror - more Muslim sects) or kill opposing sects (by doing stuff like writing sacred texts in a dead language and complaining that nobody reads them - lose some Hindus). These cards don't add a whole hell of a lot to the game, outside of being damned funny. It's worth getting the expansion just to read the clever crap at the bottom.

One thing that deserves special notice is the production value in this game. Balls Out Entertainment must have hit the lotto, because this game has to cost a bundle to make. The art is perfect. The figures in the game are flat-out gorgeous - easily the most beautiful sculpts I've ever seen on board game pawns (as long as you can find beauty in sacrilege - and I can). The cards are slick and durable. The board is fun to look at. In short, Playing Gods is put together so well, you'll wonder how they can afford to sell you a copy for forty bucks.

Of course, my opinion might be a little biased - I don't believe in any of these religions (except maybe Oprah. How can you not love Oprah? Oh, wait, it's because she's a complete waste of oxygen). So I love being able to play a game that holds up organized religion and says, 'hey, this is kind of stupid.'

Summary

Pros:
Great theme (if you don't mind blasphemy - and I don't)
Plays incredibly fast - turns might only last ten seconds
Absolutely hilarious, I don't care who you are

Cons:
Limited strategic options
More than slightly sacreligious (wait, should that be under Pros?)
Last edited on 2008-11-20 17:09:16 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
Dear Scott, how about lifting the bans?
flag
Avatar
06070809
Great little review -

You hit the nail on the head!

:D


galen Carter-Jeffrey
flag
Avatar
04
I played the game a few weeks back and I thought it was rather boring. It's a typical roll and move game.

While the theme is funny got about 5 minutes the game takes about 90 minutes to play. With very little strategy going on this feels like an all day event.
Thomas Taylor
flag
Avatar
0708
I dunno about you guys, but far as I'm concerned, blasphemy rules.
Daniel Cain
flag
Avatar
0708
Tygo wrote:
I dunno about you guys, but far as I'm concerned, blasphemy rules.


The game Blasphemydoes not rule. Actual blasphemy does rule though.

I guess I will still be looking for a game that pokes fun at organized religion. This does not sound like my cup of tea, but those figures are freakin sweet!

LA
Anthony DuLac
flag
Avatar
08
Well-written review and thanks for warning me to avoid this very cheesy (and lame) sounding game. Definitely not a game that I'd find funny or fun.
Dear Scott, how about lifting the bans?
flag
Avatar
06070809
galeninjapan wrote:
I played the game a few weeks back and I thought it was rather boring. It's a typical roll and move game.

While the theme is funny got about 5 minutes the game takes about 90 minutes to play. With very little strategy going on this feels like an all day event.

I think, a deep heavy-weight game would not match the satirical viewpoint. You can hardly play seriously, when the second aim of the game is mocking about stupidity incarnating in religions.

I still haven`t played it yet (but my family absolutely wants to, so we will see) - but I don`t expect anything "deep". Maybe someone can find a twist or houserule to make it more "tactical" or "strategical" (or only shorter?) ... so far it rather looks like an accurate "realistic" approach, since all catastrophes and their impact on certain sects are - totally random ... :)
galen Carter-Jeffrey
flag
Avatar
04
Let me put it this way, there is more strategy in a game of munchkin and more humor in a game of flux...
James King
flag

VixenTorGames wrote:
Let's assume you just read the title of this game and weren't offended right off the bat. Maybe you said, 'you know, I'm not really sure what that's about, maybe it won't be as bad as it sounds.' If that's what you said, I hate to tell you this, but you're about to be disappointed.

"Playing Gods" isn't just accidentally or mildly offensive. Each player takes on the role of a deity trying to obliterate all the others gods by recruiting or decimating their followers. Buddha carries a chain gun. Allah carries a bomb. And the most offensive of all of these gods is Jesus, who is swinging a giant cross with a spike in the crossbar. In fact, I think it's just a contest at this point to see who blows up Balls Out Entertainment first - crazed Muslims or rabid Christians. My money is on the Muslims. They were going to bomb that Danish newspaper just for a bunch of cartoons. An actual statue of Allah carrying a bomb has got to put them over the top.

And therein lie the flaws that torpedo the notion behind the game and literally blow it out of the water altogether: Without any sense of perspective or focus, the game attempts to lambaste and scapegoat all major organized religions by broadly amd disingenuously defining them by their most fundementalist-extremist elements who are more often than not engaging in their own twisted form of religiosity than the actual tenets of their respective religions. In that respect, I very much doubt that this game would even be genuinely enjoyed by people who enjoyed comedian/commentator Bill Maher's recent "Religulous" documentary.

So, without that sort of focus, I would have to infer that the game's intended target market would be fanatical atheists who decry organized religion but who see no hypocrisy in their organizing themselves as in such a way as to resembled a de-facto organized religion themselves, even going so far as to sing atheist "hymns" (earnestly reworded classic religious hymns sung to the same music as the origial religious hymn, only extolling the virtues of atheism). Somehow, I doubt that atheists would take too kindly to fanatical atheism being cast as the sixth god in the game and depicted by a ranting, snarling bigot breaking a crucifix across his knee.

If the game designers had had any genuine sense of even-handed proportionality in implementing barbed satiric humor and edifying intent in their game, they would have created "Playing God: The Game of Fundementalist Extremismm, Renegade Religiosity and Cults of Pompous Personality."

But they lost me altogether on this one. Moreover, they probably need not worry about being bombed by any extremists as their extreme concept would appear to be in the process of imploding quite well on its own even now with most folks.
galen Carter-Jeffrey
flag
Avatar
04
There is more controversy in an episode of south park than this game and at least south park is funny, relevant and timely.
Jay LaFountain
flag
They should've gone for the Jesus with the cords whipping people out of the temple... at least it is in the Bible, and then any Christians taking offense could be easily ridiculed!

And that's what this game is all about, ridiculing people.
Dear Scott, how about lifting the bans?
flag
Avatar
06070809