geek
The Hotness
Games|People|Company
Rules | Subscriptions | Bookmarks | Search | Account | Moderators
Recommend
6
16 Posts
New Thread | Printer Friendly | Subscribe  sub options | Bookmark
Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Eddy B
United States
Wichita
Kansas
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmb
The Settlers of Catan » Forums » Reviews
"Shockers" Settlers of Catan Review
There are tons of reviews out there by now but nothing really really recent. Figured it couldn't hurt to add my version of what I thought since I'm late in the game on Catan.

For the longest time I've been hearing about this "gateway game". A few of my friends had it but I always chose to play other games. Figured it couldn't be that good of a game seeing as how dice were involved. Well a few months ago, I finally gave in and tried it out. Love the game. There are some serious flaws in it that I dislike but I can get over them.

After the three months, I've put in many sessions, played online and just purchased it on Amazon thanks to their $19.99 deal

The Rules:
The rules are extremely simple. I won't get into the specifics as i'm sure nearly everybody knows how to play. Explaining the rules was a breeze to all. Easy to learn, and maybe a game or two to get the hang of it. Then a few more on top of that to get a good strategy going.

The Gameplay/Mechanics.
The Gameplay is so simple, you just place your pieces on the board for where you want to start. Roll the dice and go from there.

There are two things I kind of dislike about the game. Number one being the aforementioned dice. It really puts a drag on the game when the cards you get are all decided on the luck of the roll. You can easily go the first five or six rounds without getting a card. When its a tight game at the end, it pretty much comes down to who can get the resources they need to build.

The second thing I dislike is the ganging up strategy. If the other participants on the game want to prevent somebody from winning, they could gang up on that person right from the start. Say I've won three games in a row, then people will see to it I don't win a fourth. They'll block you and constantly place robbers on you if they want to play that way.

But if you can look past both of those negatives, its actually a pretty fun game to play. You honestly don't have to put much thought into the game and the game moves quicker than most Euros i've played. In a 3-4 player game, you could probably finish in 30 minutes or so depending on how long everybody takes to think and do the trading.

The trading is a fun aspect of the game. You're trying to benefit yourself but need to help others out too if you're trying to get a trade to work. There really isn't even a foolproof strategy. A lot of it depends on what tiles are placed near what numbers. My goal is to always try and build cities as fast as I can but others have caught on and do the same thing. Plus if the necessary resources are taken up at the start, then I have to change it up. You can try and get development cards, get the longest road, build the largest armies, you have to find that good balance to get you the victory. There are a lot of variables to take into account on top of the luck of the dice. And sometimes if you're not getting the dice, you might have to make that trade or change up the strategy to see if you can sneak a victory out which is always possible.

Final Thoughts:
I now know why they call this the gateway game. The simplicity of it gets people to really start to familiarize themselves with those other Euro games.

Its a quick play that doesn't take hours on end like others Ive tried.

After the first try, I was hooked. Played it again and again. Tried the online versions for practice and it helped quite a bit. For $19.99 on amazon right now, that's a steal. Many of the B&M stores around here charge $40 for it.

This is a great addition to any collection. I'm glad I finally caved in and tried it out.
Eddy B
United States
Wichita
Kansas
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmb
BTW, does anybody have any good suggestions on the first expansion I should get?
William McDuff
Canada
Petit-Rocher-Sud
New Brunswick
flag msg tools
Avatar
patron09
mbmbmbmbmb
I'd go with the 5-6 Player expansion if you have a larger group to play with, or Cities & Knights if you don't.
Marshall P.
United States
Wichita
Kansas
flag msg tools
Avatar
040506070809
mbmbmbmbmb
edytwinky wrote:
BTW, does anybody have any good suggestions on the first expansion I should get?


My opinion is that this is one game that shouldn't be expanded. The expansions all make the game considerably longer, which to me isn't supported by the gameplay. If I have more time or more people there are plenty of other games I'd rather play. If I have 4 people and an hour then a game of Settlers isn't such a bad idea.
Eddy B
United States
Wichita
Kansas
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmb
wmcduff wrote:
I'd go with the 5-6 Player expansion if you have a larger group to play with, or Cities & Knights if you don't.


Yeah, i've played the 5-6 player expansion. Not a big fan. Almost too crowded and too much going on, people move to slow, etc. Kind of takes away from the real game.

I was looking at Fisherman of Catan and looks pretty cool.
Sven T.
Germany
Düsseldorf
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmb
mdp4828 wrote:
My opinion is that this is one game that shouldn't be expanded.


I disagree. We never play without Cities & Knights, because the base game, once you get to know it, gets a bit boring with it's limited options. So C&K is the expansion I recommend.

Of course, Marshall has a point there: The game will be longer. If you like short games with a limited, but clear set of options, an expansion with it's added complexity will propably take away some of the fun. But you never know unless you tried, do you?
Tomello Visello
United States
Reston
Virginia
flag msg tools
patron070809
mbmbmbmbmb
edytwinky wrote:
Yeah, i've played the 5-6 player expansion. Not a big fan. Almost too crowded and too much going on, people move to slow, etc. Kind of takes away from the real game.
So. Seafarers? That gets you off the island.

Mitch Brink


msg tools
Hello. Brand new here.
I just got Settlers of Catan on the recommendation of a friend.
We love it. I have to admit, I didn't realize there was a world of board games out there beyond Monopoly and the rest of the toy-isle games.

So, since Settlers is considered a gateway game, what should our next game be? We can't really commit to games that take many hours. 1-2 hours is about right for our family.

Thanks!
Last edited on 2008-12-27 10:58:45 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
Eddy B
United States
Wichita
Kansas
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmb
mitchb2 wrote:
Hello. Brand new here.
I just got Settlers of Catan on the recommendation of a friend.
We love it. I have to admit, I didn't realize there was a world of board games out there beyond Monopoly and the rest of the toy-isle games.

So, since Settlers is considered a gateway game, what should our next game be? We can't really commit to games that take many hours. 1-2 hours is about right for our family.

Thanks!


Try Power Grid. I just wrote a review for it here: http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/367011

As for somebody mentioning Seafarers earlier, a buddy just got it for Christmas. I'll be giving that a try shortly.
Sven T.
Germany
Düsseldorf
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmb
mitchb2 wrote:
So, since Settlers is considered a gateway game, what should our next game be?


Welcome to the Geek. You may want to take a look at Alhambra http://www.boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/6249 or Carcassonne http://www.boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/822. Both games qualify with short rulesets, playing time of approx. 45-60 minutes and great replay value.
Tomello Visello
United States
Reston
Virginia
flag msg tools
patron070809
mbmbmbmbmb
mitchb2 wrote:
So, since Settlers is considered a gateway game, what should our next game be? We can't really commit to games that take many hours. 1-2 hours is about right for our family.
Other titles of Gateway status are good choices. In the SEARCH bar near the top of the page, choose GeekLists in the drop-down list and search for the term GATEWAY to see candidates mentioned in past discussions.

http://boardgamegeek.com/geeklist_controller.php?action=sear...

Geoff Burkman
United States
Kettering
Ohio
flag msg tools
patron08
mbmbmbmbmb
edytwinky wrote:
BTW, does anybody have any good suggestions on the first expansion I should get?


My recommendation is "Cities & Knights." I believe Klaus Teuber is on record as saying that's the game he intended "Settlers of Catan" to be. Imho, it's far superior to vanilla "Settler." I suppose it depends on the gaming sophistication of your group/family, though. Kids might be more amenable to "Seafarers" or "Fisherman," both of which are very simplistic add-ons.
Geoff Burkman
United States
Kettering
Ohio
flag msg tools
patron08
mbmbmbmbmb
mitchb2 wrote:
Hello. Brand new here.
I just got Settlers of Catan on the recommendation of a friend.
We love it. I have to admit, I didn't realize there was a world of board games out there beyond Monopoly and the rest of the toy-isle games. So, since Settlers is considered a gateway game, what should our next game be? We can't really commit to games that take many hours. 1-2 hours is about right for our family. Thanks!


Unsurprisingly, my recommendation is going to be Agricola. Or Carcassonne, if you'd like to try a tile-building game.
John Hawksley
United States
San Mateo
California
flag msg tools
patron09
Or any Days of Wonder game, I think they are easy to love especially for casual/diverse groups.
Clay Hales
United States
Findlay
Ohio
flag msg tools
mb
I just played my first game of Catan on New Year's Eve. I had a good enough time, and I'm sure I'd have fun if I play more.

I can see what you mean by the dice dictating cards is a potential problem. I was a victim of unlucky dice for most of the game. I was in a position to just about have a monopoly on brick from the beginning and the only time I got brick was on the first card draw.

It's a fun game, but I don't really think I will be going out of my way to play it again. I know I'll have plenty of opportunities to play it again from here on out, but it just didn't pull me in like I thought it should (I mean everyone on the planet but me has played this thing).

Edit: I should have mentioned to begin with that the friends that have this prefer Cities and Knights to "vanilla" Catan. I think that might be what the doctor ordered.
Last edited on 2009-01-02 22:15:18 CST (Total Number of Edits: 1)
Mitch Brink


msg tools
Thanks for all the responses.
I'll check out the titles and links mentioned.
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
BoardGameGeek and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.