41 TRADES FOUND:
6 sends to 41 and receives from 30
41 sends to 13 and receives from 6
13 sends to 39 and receives from 41
39 sends to 17 and receives from 13
17 sends to 28 and receives from 39
28 sends to 26 and receives from 17
26 sends to 4 and receives from 28
4 sends to 51 and receives from 26
51 sends to 9 and receives from 4
9 sends to 8 and receives from 51
8 sends to 53 and receives from 9
53 sends to 5 and receives from 8
5 sends to 16 and receives from 53
16 sends to 38 and receives from 5
38 sends to 37 and receives from 16
37 sends to 3 and receives from 38
3 sends to 35 and receives from 37
35 sends to 29 and receives from 3
29 sends to 57 and receives from 35
57 sends to 56 and receives from 29
56 sends to 40 and receives from 57
40 sends to 58 and receives from 56
58 sends to 47 and receives from 40
47 sends to 31 and receives from 58
31 sends to 50 and receives from 47
50 sends to 10 and receives from 31
10 sends to 21 and receives from 50
21 sends to 25 and receives from 10
25 sends to 20 and receives from 21
20 sends to 2 and receives from 25
2 sends to 42 and receives from 20
42 sends to 54 and receives from 2
54 sends to 11 and receives from 42
11 sends to 24 and receives from 54
24 sends to 46 and receives from 11
46 sends to 44 and receives from 24
44 sends to 36 and receives from 46
36 sends to 15 and receives from 44
15 sends to 27 and receives from 36
27 sends to 30 and receives from 15
30 sends to 6 and receives from 27

Or to put it another way:
Anyone for cricket? sends Through the Desert to tim-pelican and receives Santiago from dipdragon
brainrob sends Mystery Rummy: Al Capone and the Chicago Underworld to Tycho and receives Bali+Fliegen (aka Pack of Flies) from ColdFinger
bucklen_uk sends Drakon+Expansion to cggritt and receives Really Nasty Horseracing Game, The from ColdFinger
bucklen_uk sends Magdar to tim-pelican and receives When Darkness Comes from kamawell
bucklen_uk sends Flaschenteufel to ColdFinger and receives Laguna+Hellas from cggritt
cggritt sends Nautilus to dipdragon and receives Drakon+Expansion from bucklen_uk
cggritt sends Laguna+Hellas to bucklen_uk and receives Andromeda from Tycho
cggritt sends Oceania+Avalon to mrraow and receives Quo Vadis? from Simon J
Chris Morriss sends ZERTZ+Im Auftrag des Konigs to tim-pelican and receives Wings of War - Famous Aces from ColdFinger
Chris__M sends Dungeon Twister to Kanedacorp and receives Hive from mrraow
Chris__M sends Star Munchkin+Expansion - Star Munchkin: The Clone Wars to Kanedacorp and receives Sorcerer's Cave, the from tim-pelican
Chris__M sends Dog's Life, A to ColdFinger and receives Executive Decision from icheyne
ColdFinger sends Really Nasty Horseracing Game, The to bucklen_uk and receives Meander from mrraow
ColdFinger sends Java to Otterdance and receives Around the World in 80 Days from Simon J
ColdFinger sends Wings of War - Famous Aces to Chris Morriss and receives Flaschenteufel from bucklen_uk
ColdFinger sends Bali+Fliegen (aka Pack of Flies) to brainrob and receives Dog's Life, A from Chris__M
dipdragon sends Santiago to Anyone for cricket? and receives Nautilus from cggritt
dipdragon sends Age of Steam to Simon J and receives Settlers of Canaan, The from Kanedacorp
dipdragon sends Valley Of The Four Winds+Cosmic Encounter to icheyne and receives King of the Elves from Tycho
dipdragon sends Babel to Simon J and receives Can't Stop from icheyne
icheyne sends Linie 1+Bang! or Nicht die Bohne to kamawell and receives Tycoon from Simon J
icheyne sends Louis XIV to Simon J and receives Fische Fluppen Frikadellen from kamawell
icheyne sends Executive Decision to Chris__M and receives Stockmarket+221B baker st (no expansions) OR Poleconomy from Kanedacorp
icheyne sends Can't Stop to dipdragon and receives Valley Of The Four Winds+Cosmic Encounter from dipdragon
kamawell sends When Darkness Comes to bucklen_uk and receives Talisman from tim-pelican
kamawell sends Fische Fluppen Frikadellen to icheyne and receives Linie 1+Bang! or Nicht die Bohne from icheyne
Kanedacorp sends Settlers of Canaan, The to dipdragon and receives Dungeon Twister from Chris__M
Kanedacorp sends Stockmarket+221B baker st (no expansions) OR Poleconomy to icheyne and receives Star Munchkin+Expansion - Star Munchkin: The Clone Wars from Chris__M
mrraow sends Meander to ColdFinger and receives Oceania+Avalon from cggritt
mrraow sends Hive to Chris__M and receives Leapfrog from tim-pelican
Otterdance sends Elfenland to Simon J and receives Dos Rios from Simon J
Otterdance sends Colossal Arena to Tycho and receives Java from ColdFinger
Simon J sends Tycoon to icheyne and receives Age of Steam from dipdragon
Simon J sends Dos Rios to Otterdance and receives Louis XIV from icheyne
Simon J sends Around the World in 80 Days to ColdFinger and receives Elfenland from Otterdance
Simon J sends Quo Vadis? to cggritt and receives Babel from dipdragon
tim-pelican sends Talisman to kamawell and receives Through the Desert from Anyone for cricket?
tim-pelican sends Leapfrog to mrraow and receives Magdar from bucklen_uk
tim-pelican sends Sorcerer's Cave, the to Chris__M and receives ZERTZ+Im Auftrag des Konigs from Chris Morriss
Tycho sends Andromeda to cggritt and receives Colossal Arena from Otterdance
Tycho sends King of the Elves to dipdragon and receives Mystery Rummy: Al Capone and the Chicago Underworld from brainrob


1 Dragon Quest + Kill Doctor lucky
2 Stockmarket + 221B baker st (no expansions) OR Poleconomy
3 Fische Fluppen Frikadellen
4 When Darkness Comes
5 Settlers of Canaan, The
6 Meander
7 Gothic Game, the
8 Hive
9 Leapfrog
10 Wings of War - Famous Aces
11 Bali + Fliegen (aka Pack of Flies)
12 Britannia
13 Drakon + Expansion
14 Euphrat & Tigris
15 Babel
16 Age of Steam
17 Santiago
18 Lord of the Rings + Sauron expansion
19 Hoity Toity
20 Star Munchkin + Expansion - Star Munchkin: The Clone Wars
21 ZERTZ + Im Auftrag des Konigs
22 Killer Bunnies and the Quest for the Magic Carrot + Green Killer bunny expansion
23 Dog Eat Dog
24 Mystery Rummy: Al Capone and the Chicago Underworld
25 Sorcerer's Cave, the
26 Talisman
27 Quo Vadis?
28 Through the Desert
29 Dos Rios
30 Oceania + Avalon
31 Laguna + Hellas
32 Um Reifenbreite
33 Sucking Vacuum
34 Warrior Knights + Thieves World
35 Louis XIV
36 Can't Stop
37 Linie 1 + Bang! or Nicht die Bohne
38 Tycoon
39 Nautilus
40 Java
41 Really Nasty Horseracing Game, The
42 Executive Decision
43 Wizard's Quest + Cosmic Encounter
44 Valley Of The Four Winds + Cosmic Encounter
45 Kablamo
46 King of the Elves
47 Andromeda
48 Weinhändler, die
49 Kingmaker
50 Flaschenteufel
51 Magdar
52 Challenge, The
53 Dungeon Twister
54 Dog's Life, A
55 Hispaniola
56 Around the World in 80 Days
57 Elfenland
58 Colossal Arena

Thanks again for organising this. Folks might find things easier if there were a link to the list - here it is:

http://www.boardgamegeek.com/geeklist.php3?action=view&listi...

Thanks Stephen, I knew I was missing something

I should have mentioned, please PM your lists to me by wednesday. I will start running tradegenie early if I get all the lists in..

I did not receive replies from 3 people, I have geekmailed them this morning. Due to the downtime of BGG I will re-start the tradegenie if I get lists from them today but if not, tradegenie is now running on this set of numbers:

6 30 31
7 5 9 30 31 39
8 5 9 30 31 39
1 20 4 14 28 29 33 40 16 7 22 39 15 21 8 3 58 12 31 6 11 38 23 35 17 51 30 10 13 34 41 45 46 53 47 52 54 56
2 20 4 14 28 29 33 40 16 7 22 39 15 21 8 3 58 12 31 6 11 38 23 35 17 51 30 10 13 34 41 45 46 53 47 52 54 56
22 16 40 17 21 24 28 35
3 37 29 35 28 26 16 40 13 15 58 49 57 6
4 37 29 35 28 26 16 40 13 15 58 49 57 6
30 40 16 37 17 53 28 3 13 27 57 56 38 47
31 40 16 37 17 53 28 3 13 27 57 56 38 47
39 40 16 37 17 53 28 3 13 27 57 56 38 47
35 3 8 29 32 38 40 44 45 47 53 58
36 3 8 29 32 38 40 44 45 47 53 58
37 3 8 29 32 38 40 44 45 47 53 58
42 2 3 8 10 29 32 38 40 44 45 47 53 58
23 5 10 29 32
24 5 10 11 27 29 32 45
18 8 4 14 16 23 57 51 58 46 40 42 39 38 34 3 5 10 13 17 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 47 56 32 33
19 8 4 14 16 23 57 51 58 46 40 42 39 38 34 3 5 10 13 17 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 47 56 32 33
20 8 4 14 16 23 57 51 58 46 40 42 39 38 34 3 5 10 13 17 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 47 56 32 33
53 8 4 14 16 23 57 51 58 46 40
54 8 4 14 16 23 57 51 58 46 40 42 39 38 34 3 5 10 13 17 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 47 56 32 33
55 8 4 14 16 23 57 51 58 46 40 42 39 38 34 3 5 10 13 17 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 47 56 32 33
40 37 56
10 37 56 35 29 6 54 50
11 37 56 35 29 6 54 50 39 31 3 27 21 9
41 37 56 35 29 6 54 50 39 31 3 27 21 9
21 10 16 17 35 56
12 17 29 35 47 56
13 10 17 27 29 30 35 41 47 56
14
49 17 29 35 47 56
50 4 10 17 24 31 36 56
51 4 10 17 27 29 30 31 35 36 41 47 56
52 4 10 17 27 29 30 31 35 36 41 47 56
57 17 16 40 10 29 35
58 16 17 10 40 29 35
9 16 10 28 58 14 29 53 36 40 56 35 4 57 21 51 13 37
25 16 10 28 58 14 29 53 36 40 56 35 4 57 21
26 16 10 28 58 14 29 53 36 40
28 17 14
5 53 28 4 20
45 57 5 35 17 3 53 24 56 14 58
46 57 5 35 17 3 53 24 56 14 58
47 57 5 35 17 3 53 24 56 14 58
48 57 5 35 17 3 53 24 56 14 58

Let me know ASAP if I seem to have any errors or omissions please

I'm one of the late replies, I couldn't get on BGG yesterday. I've now sent my list to Matt.

27 35 16 17 57 40 53 58 15 8 50
29 35 16 17 57 40 53 58
38 35 16 17 57 40 53 58 15 8 50
56 35 16 17 57 40 53

41 TRADES FOUND:
6 sends to 41 and receives from 30
41 sends to 13 and receives from 6
13 sends to 39 and receives from 41
39 sends to 17 and receives from 13
17 sends to 28 and receives from 39
28 sends to 26 and receives from 17
26 sends to 4 and receives from 28
4 sends to 51 and receives from 26
51 sends to 9 and receives from 4
9 sends to 8 and receives from 51
8 sends to 53 and receives from 9
53 sends to 5 and receives from 8
5 sends to 16 and receives from 53
16 sends to 38 and receives from 5
38 sends to 37 and receives from 16
37 sends to 3 and receives from 38
3 sends to 35 and receives from 37
35 sends to 29 and receives from 3
29 sends to 57 and receives from 35
57 sends to 56 and receives from 29
56 sends to 40 and receives from 57
40 sends to 58 and receives from 56
58 sends to 47 and receives from 40
47 sends to 31 and receives from 58
31 sends to 50 and receives from 47
50 sends to 10 and receives from 31
10 sends to 21 and receives from 50
21 sends to 25 and receives from 10
25 sends to 20 and receives from 21
20 sends to 2 and receives from 25
2 sends to 42 and receives from 20
42 sends to 54 and receives from 2
54 sends to 11 and receives from 42
11 sends to 24 and receives from 54
24 sends to 46 and receives from 11
46 sends to 44 and receives from 24
44 sends to 36 and receives from 46
36 sends to 15 and receives from 44
15 sends to 27 and receives from 36
27 sends to 30 and receives from 15
30 sends to 6 and receives from 27

Or to put it another way:
Anyone for cricket? sends Through the Desert to tim-pelican and receives Santiago from dipdragon
brainrob sends Mystery Rummy: Al Capone and the Chicago Underworld to Tycho and receives Bali+Fliegen (aka Pack of Flies) from ColdFinger
bucklen_uk sends Drakon+Expansion to cggritt and receives Really Nasty Horseracing Game, The from ColdFinger
bucklen_uk sends Magdar to tim-pelican and receives When Darkness Comes from kamawell
bucklen_uk sends Flaschenteufel to ColdFinger and receives Laguna+Hellas from cggritt
cggritt sends Nautilus to dipdragon and receives Drakon+Expansion from bucklen_uk
cggritt sends Laguna+Hellas to bucklen_uk and receives Andromeda from Tycho
cggritt sends Oceania+Avalon to mrraow and receives Quo Vadis? from Simon J
Chris Morriss sends ZERTZ+Im Auftrag des Konigs to tim-pelican and receives Wings of War - Famous Aces from ColdFinger
Chris__M sends Dungeon Twister to Kanedacorp and receives Hive from mrraow
Chris__M sends Star Munchkin+Expansion - Star Munchkin: The Clone Wars to Kanedacorp and receives Sorcerer's Cave, the from tim-pelican
Chris__M sends Dog's Life, A to ColdFinger and receives Executive Decision from icheyne
ColdFinger sends Really Nasty Horseracing Game, The to bucklen_uk and receives Meander from mrraow
ColdFinger sends Java to Otterdance and receives Around the World in 80 Days from Simon J
ColdFinger sends Wings of War - Famous Aces to Chris Morriss and receives Flaschenteufel from bucklen_uk
ColdFinger sends Bali+Fliegen (aka Pack of Flies) to brainrob and receives Dog's Life, A from Chris__M
dipdragon sends Santiago to Anyone for cricket? and receives Nautilus from cggritt
dipdragon sends Age of Steam to Simon J and receives Settlers of Canaan, The from Kanedacorp
dipdragon sends Valley Of The Four Winds+Cosmic Encounter to icheyne and receives King of the Elves from Tycho
dipdragon sends Babel to Simon J and receives Can't Stop from icheyne
icheyne sends Linie 1+Bang! or Nicht die Bohne to kamawell and receives Tycoon from Simon J
icheyne sends Louis XIV to Simon J and receives Fische Fluppen Frikadellen from kamawell
icheyne sends Executive Decision to Chris__M and receives Stockmarket+221B baker st (no expansions) OR Poleconomy from Kanedacorp
icheyne sends Can't Stop to dipdragon and receives Valley Of The Four Winds+Cosmic Encounter from dipdragon
kamawell sends When Darkness Comes to bucklen_uk and receives Talisman from tim-pelican
kamawell sends Fische Fluppen Frikadellen to icheyne and receives Linie 1+Bang! or Nicht die Bohne from icheyne
Kanedacorp sends Settlers of Canaan, The to dipdragon and receives Dungeon Twister from Chris__M
Kanedacorp sends Stockmarket+221B baker st (no expansions) OR Poleconomy to icheyne and receives Star Munchkin+Expansion - Star Munchkin: The Clone Wars from Chris__M
mrraow sends Meander to ColdFinger and receives Oceania+Avalon from cggritt
mrraow sends Hive to Chris__M and receives Leapfrog from tim-pelican
Otterdance sends Elfenland to Simon J and receives Dos Rios from Simon J
Otterdance sends Colossal Arena to Tycho and receives Java from ColdFinger
Simon J sends Tycoon to icheyne and receives Age of Steam from dipdragon
Simon J sends Dos Rios to Otterdance and receives Louis XIV from icheyne
Simon J sends Around the World in 80 Days to ColdFinger and receives Elfenland from Otterdance
Simon J sends Quo Vadis? to cggritt and receives Babel from dipdragon
tim-pelican sends Talisman to kamawell and receives Through the Desert from Anyone for cricket?
tim-pelican sends Leapfrog to mrraow and receives Magdar from bucklen_uk
tim-pelican sends Sorcerer's Cave, the to Chris__M and receives ZERTZ+Im Auftrag des Konigs from Chris Morriss
Tycho sends Andromeda to cggritt and receives Colossal Arena from Otterdance
Tycho sends King of the Elves to dipdragon and receives Mystery Rummy: Al Capone and the Chicago Underworld from brainrob

Thanks Matt! I got everything I wanted. I hope we can run another one of these again as I have a couple of games left over. I don't monitor the trades folder, so please message me if anyone runs one of these again.

Just out of interest, is there an easy way to list the spinster games that got left on the shelf?

Well, not my dream results, but some exchanges I'm perfectly happy with. Is there a usual way to follow up on these - ie through the trade manager so everyone gets the 'good trader' brownie points, or just PM? If the former, is it the sender or the receiver who initiates each link?

Also, I'll echo the thanks to Matt for running this.

I'm pleasantly surprised with how that turned out. Having never participated in a Math trade before, I didn't quite fully appreciate how it turns into a multi-sided exchange.

Many thanks to Matt for organising it.

Chris

The Math Trade guide says:


http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/93555

All my transfers now complete. Many thanks to everyone involved in them, and especially to Matt for suggesting and organising this Maths Trade.

Great job, Matt. Thanks for taking the time to run this.

Mikko Saari has put together a new Math Trade tool ( http://www.melankolia.net/gameblog/archives/2006/05/math_tra...).

Just out of interest, it found 44 trades on our data:

44 TRADES FOUND:
52 sends to 2 and receives from 10
2 sends to 42 and receives from 52
42 sends to 20 and receives from 2
20 sends to 5 and receives from 42
5 sends to 46 and receives from 20
46 sends to 53 and receives from 5
53 sends to 25 and receives from 46
25 sends to 54 and receives from 53
54 sends to 10 and receives from 25
10 sends to 52 and receives from 54

29 sends to 12 and receives from 17
12 sends to 44 and receives from 29
44 sends to 36 and receives from 12
36 sends to 26 and receives from 44
26 sends to 4 and receives from 36
4 sends to 50 and receives from 26
50 sends to 41 and receives from 4
41 sends to 13 and receives from 50
13 sends to 30 and receives from 41
30 sends to 6 and receives from 13
6 sends to 11 and receives from 30
11 sends to 24 and receives from 6
24 sends to 47 and receives from 11
47 sends to 31 and receives from 24
31 sends to 51 and receives from 47
51 sends to 9 and receives from 31
9 sends to 8 and receives from 51
8 sends to 27 and receives from 9
27 sends to 39 and receives from 8
39 sends to 17 and receives from 27
17 sends to 29 and receives from 39

49 sends to 3 and receives from 35
3 sends to 15 and receives from 49
15 sends to 38 and receives from 3
38 sends to 37 and receives from 15
37 sends to 40 and receives from 38
40 sends to 58 and receives from 37
58 sends to 45 and receives from 40
45 sends to 35 and receives from 58
35 sends to 49 and receives from 45

57 sends to 56 and receives from 16
56 sends to 21 and receives from 57
21 sends to 16 and receives from 56
16 sends to 57 and receives from 21

Interesting... I got three games in the original trade (which I'm very happy with) and with the new tool I would have got...

the same three games!

Is anyone still subscribed to this thread, and if so, is there any interest in running another of these? I wouldn't mind trying to run one if the interest is there.

I'm up for it.

Yes, I would be happy to give it a try again.

Yeah, I'd give it another go

Why not try again - I'm ready to trade one of the games I got the first time

Yes, I'd do it again too. Mikko's tool would have found me one additional trade, so I'd be all in favour of that. I'm afraid I'm not volunteering to run it.

Too late now, but what would have been interesting is a math-based Manorcon swapmeet. Surely many people here are attending, or know someone else who is.

count me in!

I'm off to Manorcon too, so happy to swap there

Has anything come of this?

If anyone starts a new UK Math Trade, please post a link here to alert those of us who don't monitor the trades forum regularly.

Meanwhile, someone else has proposed a European Maths Trade.

http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/118539

I'm planning to start a UK maths trade in the next couple of weeks. I was going to start sooner, but life got in the way!

I'll post a notice to this forum.

Thanks for the European link!

Cool, thanks Christopher.

No hurry, as far as I am concerned - I just didn't want to miss it if it had started!

Chris