Didn't do anything for me. Kept losing survivors due to bad rolls. I got to sit and watch everybody else take several actions while I didn't really do much of anything. Makes for a lousy experience. Not too mention you really don't ever associate yourself as one of the characters. I guess they're just a disposable resource. Add a silly (tacked on) betrayer role and it's just the icing on the cake. Forcing everything to come down to the roll of a die is just a lazy mechanic. Don't really feel like there's any real decision making. It's all mechanical.