geek
Hot Games
Blackbeard
Agricola
Race for the Galaxy
Puerto Rico
Risk
Conquistador
Settlers of Catan, The
Pandemic
Stone Age
Last Night on Earth: The Zombie Game
Power Grid
Through the Ages: A Story of Civilization
Arkham Horror
Amazing Space Venture
StarCraft: The Board Game
Twilight Struggle
War of the Ring
A Touch of Evil, The Supernatural Game
Galactic Emperor
Descent: The Road to Legend
Carcassonne
Descent: Journeys in the Dark
Perikles
Tigris & Euphrates
The Devil's Cauldron: The Battles for Arnhem and Nijmegen
BattleLore
Dirge: Carnage in Crimson
Twilight Imperium 3rd Edition
Caylus
Shogun
Hanging Gardens, The
Race for the Galaxy: The Gathering Storm
Ticket to Ride
Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage
Commands & Colors: Ancients
El Grande
Lost Cities
Dungeons & Dragons Board Game
Galaxy Trucker
Titan
Last Night On Earth: Growing Hunger
Scrabble
Tide of Iron
Kingsburg
Age of Piracy
1960: The Making of the President
Brass
Combat Commander: Europe
Clue
Manoeuvre
Color Blind Images
Topher Frisco
flag
Avatar
060708
Recommend
343
I am not color blind. I don't purport to understand the frustration and handicap that this presents in life. However, I have seen the frustration first hand as I play with and have friends and family who are color blind. All of the people I know have trouble, in general, distinguishing between red and green (appearing to them as brown).

I discovered a web site called Vischeck (via a geek list) - http://www.vischeck.com/vischeck/vischeckImage.php, which lets you upload images to see how they might appear if you were color blind. It also includes a plug-in for Photoshop! Some of the images below I've created myself, but others I've 'borrowed'. My thanks (and apologies) to the individuals who created the images I've used for this purpose.

There have been quite a number of threads on the BGG concerning this, all with very good information and links to resources. But for those of us who are not color blind I thought it would be enlightening to quickly see what 7-10% of all males and 4% (or less) of females see by manipulating existing images here on the geek. There are different forms of this; an insensitivity to red, green, or both. This list only concentrates on one of those, Deuteranope, an insensitivity to green.

Some great, previous geek lists about this topic:
"ROYGBIV? More like ROY(R/G?)B(dB)(drB)*.": How I Modified My Games So I Could Actually Play Them: http://www.boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/17031
Colorblind-Friendly Games: The Counterpoint to My Other GeekList: http://www.boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/17103
Games for color blind people to avoid: http://www.boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/15772
Games by color-blind buddy Kevin can play: http://www.boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/831
Games that use color as the only way to communicate something - not colorblind friendly: http://www.boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/9917
Colorblind unfriendly games: http://www.boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/2706
You don't even have to be colour blind: http://www.boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/12408

The games below I selected based on reading through the geek lists above and from my own experience playing with color blind friends/family. It would be wonderful if games had a color blind rating (if only here on BGG).

NOTE: My grades below are based entirely on what I'm seeing when I convert them, not what I've been told by individuals. Please comment and/or update my initial grades accordingly.

For all of the image pairs below, the image on the left (or top) is the 'normal' view, and the image on the right (or bottom) is the best approximation that technology can provide for what an average person sees who suffers from green insensitivity.

Even though the Vischeck site provides you with ample resources to produce the types of images below, I would be happy to convert anyone's images. One of the items in this list is a screen shot of the Photoshop plug-in. If you know specifics about your (or a loved one's) specific color-blind condition, I would be glad to convert any images for you.
Your Tags: View |
Popular Tags: [View All]
Posted On: 2007-06-25 17:38:10
Edited On: 2007-06-26 11:24:08

1. Caylus [Average Rating:8.11 Unranked]
Topher Frisco
flag
Avatar
060708
Grade for Caylus: B
( upgraded from a C to a B based on Arthur's comments )

Unfortunately I don't own this game, so I'm using images available here on the geek. I've indicated the orignial creators of the images (in parenthesis). Many of the images you will need to click to see the larger versions to get a better idea. For Caylus, notice the difference (or lack thereof) between the pink and dark blue.

The Board (original by Karis):
For all of the images the left-hand image is 'normal' and the right-hand image is what an average red-green color blind person sees.
Original:
Color-Blind:


The Bits (original by ZiggyZambo):
Color-Blind:


The Building Tiles (original by Karis):

Color-Blind:
16 Comments [Hide]
Posted On: 2007-04-02 13:09:01
Edited on: 2007-06-26 11:02:50
Comment
I think the colour-blind version of the second image actually looks cooler.
Kevin Cowtan
flag
Avatar
0708
I'm a severe protanope, but I have no trouble with Caylus - I'd give it a B.
Robert Schimkowitsch
flag
Avatar
Another interesting point would be the player pieces:

(created by pitarque) versus

1
Michael M.
flag
Avatar
That's a pretty good program. I'm mildly color blind and I could not tell the difference between the two pictures if my life depended on it.
6
Mike Adams
flag
Avatar
05
I showed this Geeklist to my son, who is not colorblind. Starting with the cube picture above he was laughing his head off. He thought they were pretty funny. And still, they look the same to me.

Really, I can't even tell you if the second photo in each instance is how I see it. The colors could still be off but end up looking the same to me anyway and there's no way I could tell.

I vote for more stylish black bits in games like in Samurai.
2
Jeff Binning
flag
05060708
I have a hard time with this game, as I can't tell the difference between the food and the stone cubes. Some games become more work than fun for me. I can manage this one, but barely.
Roger Munk
flag
050607
Why did you start with this game? :D Have you been able to play this one again? This one isn't too bad for me-the cubes are what I have a bit of trouble with and I'm a total protanope. I couldn't see any difference between the images.
Topher Frisco
flag
Avatar
060708
Rog. wrote:
Why did you start with this game? :D Have you been able to play this one again? This one isn't too bad for me-the cubes are what I have a bit of trouble with and I'm a total protanope. I couldn't see any difference between the images.
Hey Roger! This was the last game that I've played with a color-blind opponent (guess who!).
:D
You have a 'bit of trouble', thus the grade of B. Do you think it should be graded a B+/A-?
Isaac -Meat is murder. Tasty, tasty murder.- Bickerstaff
flag
Avatar
0405060708
Asperamanca wrote:
Another interesting point would be the player pieces:

(created by pitarque) versus



Now THESE I can tell apart. The red piece in the second photo looks green to me.
Tim Bass
flag
Avatar
I agree the toughest part for me on this game is the food and stone cubes. Other than that, I don't have much of an issue with it.

All the images look the same to me as well. (mild red & green colorblind)
Roger Munk
flag
050607
cdefrisco wrote:
Rog. wrote:
Why did you start with this game? :D Have you been able to play this one again? This one isn't too bad for me-the cubes are what I have a bit of trouble with and I'm a total protanope. I couldn't see any difference between the images.
Hey Roger! This was the last game that I've played with a color-blind opponent (guess who!).
:D
You have a 'bit of trouble', thus the grade of B. Do you think it should be graded a B+/A-?


I would never tell someone not to play this because of color-blindness, but I guess I'd leave it as a B so that they will change it to something better on the reprint. ;)
Vitriool
flag
I'm thoroughly color blind and hardly see a difference between red-green-brown and blue-purple-black.

I played Caylus several times and I can not even see a difference between pink and grey :( Up to me, I find it one of the hardest to play (Skyline is on top with its blue and violet buildings).

Notwithstanding the high rate and the complexity of Caylus making it a very nice and replayable game full of strategy, I think all my opponents were rather bored due to my constantly asking what was pink, what was grey, what was green, what was red...

But anyway, after all the boardgames I've played, I've got used to it and I have lovely friends who are still (imagine ;)) amused with my color blindness and do not bother at all. In fact, they started to use "my terminology" while playing games. For example, only after six months I realized there was no "brown" in Schotten Totten but "dark green". Kinda strange if you called that brown for almost half a year :D
Josh K.
flag
Avatar
060708
I'm red-green, pretty severe, and hated Caylus for this reason. Both the tiles and the bits were terrible to my eyes. There were pink(?) and grey(?) cubes that were indistinguishable.