geek
Bazaar
Misc
Help
QuickBar
SEARCH
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
[+] [+]
[+] [+]
[+] [+]
[+] [+]
[+] [+]
Spiel des Jahres Face-Off: Round 1
Joe Huber
Recommend
32
I recently heard someone (who I shall allow to remain anonymous) mention that they felt Zooloretto was their least favorite of the SdJ winners. Which had me wondering - if comparing the games directly, which Spiel des Jahres winner would BGG choose as the _best_ of the lot?

There have now been 29 SdJ winners, so we'll give the three highest rated winners (El Grande, Settlers, and Ticket To Ride) a bye. So to start, we need to weed 26 SdJ winners down to 13.

For each pair, please give a thumbs up to the SdJ winner you prefer. Please feel welcome to comment on _why_ as well - I'm sure, from a historical perspective, the comments will be the most interesting aspect - but only thumbs will be counted.

The results will be taken, and the next round started, on Friday, August 10th.
Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Posted Tue Aug 7, 2007 4:23 pm
1 , 2  Next »   | 
1. Board Game: Carcassonne [Average Rating:7.52 Overall Rank:58]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 2001 SdJ winner, and #4 seed, Carcassonne...
166
Jeroen van der Valk
flag
Avatar
0406070809
This was my first modern Eurogame, and the game that started me back in boardgaming 4 years ago after a ten year hiatus. It's offspring is certainly better, but the blue box will always have a place in my collection.
2. Board Game: Enchanted Forest [Average Rating:5.79 Overall Rank:2703]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 1982 SdJ winner, and #29 seed, Enchanted Forest?
13
Chris Bailey
flag
Avatar
05
What do you think of this game Joe? Have you played it? I'm not familiar with it but if it won the SDJ...
What Randy said. I've never played Enchanted Forest but I'm pretty sure I'll prefer it to Carcassone.

So thumbsup for Enchanted Forest.
Joe Huber
ixnay66 wrote:
What do you think of this game Joe? Have you played it? I'm not familiar with it but if it won the SDJ...


It's a decent little game - there's a memory element, as a result of which it often is considered a children's game, but it's a fine family game.

I prefer Carcassonne, but not by any huge amount...
Stephen Groves
flag
Yes, this is definitely more of a kids game than we see in recent SDJ. It involves luck and uses a die which don't seem to be in favour with "true gamers". However, it is a lot of fun for anyone who plays it and doesn't outstay its welcome. Both are great games and both deserve merit. It is hard to go up against Carcassonne though as that is a great bridging game between light games and the more thinkie ones(the greatest I've found).
Edited Wed Aug 8, 2007 11:28 pm
J W
flag
Avatar
05060708
sevorges wrote:
However, it is a lot of fun for anyone who plays it and doesn't outstay its welcome.

I like the game just fine, but it definitely outstays its welcome from time to time. The "land on you and knock you back to start" rule can create a really annoying series of unproductive moves.
3. Board Game: Tikal [Average Rating:7.44 Overall Rank:74]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 1999 SdJ winner, and #5 seed, Tikal...
132
7 comments [Hide]
Edited Tue Aug 7, 2007 3:52 pm
Subscribe  | Comment
James Davis
flag
Avatar
08
anything is better than rummikub
thumbsup for Tikal.
Beautiful board & parts. Nice gateway for gamer's games. Although I prefer Java in the series.
James Davis
flag
Avatar
08
Tatsu wrote:
jamesdavis wrote:
anything is better than rummikub

Untrue. Rummikub is one of the un-sung games that gets overlooked a lot just because its available commercially everywhere. This game rewards quick and clever pattern matching. I think I enjoy Tikal better, but Rummikub is not a bad game.


Its just skip bo with tiles.
Jeroen van der Valk
flag
Avatar
0406070809
One of my favorite all-time games.
Carl Parsons
flag
Avatar
0405060708
GameMasterX0 wrote:
Anything, perhaps, except for this beautiful but analysis-paralyzing game.


I've experienced considerably more AP while playing Rummikub than Tikal.

Not by me. (edit): The AP that is.
Edited Wed Aug 8, 2007 9:42 pm
4. Board Game: Rummikub [Average Rating:6.12 Overall Rank:1287]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 1980 SdJ winner, and #28 seed, Rummikub?
49
I've never played Rummikub, but I have played Tikal, which explains why I voted for Rummikub.
James Davis
flag
Avatar
08
Randy Cox wrote:
I've never played Rummikub, but I have played Tikal, which explains why I voted for Rummikub.


I really suggest giving Rummikub a go Randy. Its best played quick and not with only 2 players.
Huzonfirst
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
050708
jamesdavis wrote:
Randy Cox wrote:
I've never played Rummikub, but I have played Tikal, which explains why I voted for Rummikub.


I really suggest giving Rummikub a go Randy. Its best played quick and not with only 2 players.

That's funny, I was just going to say the same thing about Tikal!

Tikal all the way to the finals, baby! :p
Dave VanderArk
flag
Avatar
0405060708
I almost voted "none of the above." I will play both games, but I don't particularly care for either of them.
5. Board Game: Torres [Average Rating:7.34 Overall Rank:109]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 2000 SdJ winner, and #6 seed, Torres...
88
6. Board Game: Auf Achse [Average Rating:6.35 Overall Rank:1095]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 1987 SdJ winner, and #27 seed, Auf Achse?
27
Dave VanderArk
flag
Avatar
0405060708
Auf Achse is one of my top ten games of all time. The perfect mix of route planning and balancing luck and strategy with risk and reward. As I've stated elsewhere, it's proof that an economic game with a roll and move mechanism and random event cards can be an excitingly playable game.

Sadly it doesn't stand a chance in this type of tourney because it has been out of print and hard to find for quite some time. It's so much more fun to play than Torres, which is enjoyable if you like doing math for fun. Which I don't.
Never spotted this one, but I'd love to try it. But I do enjoy Torres quite a plastic bit.
Joe Huber
David Vander Ark wrote:
Sadly it doesn't stand a chance in this type of tourney because it has been out of print and hard to find for quite some time. It's so much more fun to play than Torres, which is enjoyable if you like doing math for fun. Which I don't.


I like doing math for fun, but still prefer Auf Achse, FWIW...
7. Board Game: Thurn and Taxis [Average Rating:7.27 Overall Rank:118]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 2006 SdJ winner, and #7 seed, Thurn & Taxis...
115
8. Board Game: Focus [Average Rating:6.60 Overall Rank:1014]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 1981 SdJ winner, and #26 seed, Focus?
26
9. Board Game: Alhambra [Average Rating:7.10 Overall Rank:169]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 2003 SdJ winner, and #8 seed, Alhambra...
93
Antonio B-D
flag
Avatar
0708
I haven't played the other game, so I won't vote, but Alhambra is one of the best (or the best) of the so-called Eurogames.

Then again, if Republic of Rome or Junta were playing there would simply be no contest.... (and I am not even talking about wargames):p
Dave VanderArk
flag
Avatar
0405060708
This game comes with material to play with 5 or 6 players, but should never be played with either of those numbers.
Carl Parsons
flag
Avatar
0405060708
Alhamblah
10. Board Game: Dampfross [Average Rating:6.53 Overall Rank:1043]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 1984 SdJ winner, and #25 seed, Dampfross?
18
I just can't figure out the fun in this one. I purchased it (and even convinced people to play it--sorry about that) solely because it had the SdJ seal of approval. But it was downright painful.
Arne Hoffmann
flag
Avatar
070809
Randy,

it is the same with me. Purchased it back in 1984 as it had the SdJ-sign but found it more than painful to play.

Dampfross actually managed to manifest a hate of railroad games in me. I did not want to play any game where you'd have to build railroad tracks and am SOOO glad that I jumped my shadow and tried Age of Steam, which soon became one of my favourite games.

Got good use from my copy last year when I printed my home-made "Hammer of the Scots" on the Dampfross-board. :D

Greetings

- Arne -
11. Board Game: Liar's Dice [Average Rating:7.07 Overall Rank:195]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 1993 SdJ winner, and #9 seed, Liar's Dice...
79
Mark
flag
Avatar
06070809

A 1993 winner.....with a BGG publish date of 1974....that actually goes back, to what, the eighteenth century?

I think the Geek should list this as public domain since this game goes back 100+ years and it seems silly to credit some publisher with it.
12. Board Game: Café International [Average Rating:6.36 Overall Rank:915]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 1989 SdJ winner, and #24 seed, Cafe International?
30
13. Board Game: Um Reifenbreite [Average Rating:7.07 Overall Rank:298]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 1992 SdJ winner, and #10 seed, Um Reifenbreite...
39
Jeroen van der Valk
flag
Avatar
0406070809
I just love this game, and play it way too little...
Stephen Groves
flag
This is a close one. I own this and my friend owns the other and begrudgingly I'd say I prefer Heimlich (although he is the one who always wants to play Um Reifenbreite). I guess it's a case of the grass is greener...
14. Board Game: Heimlich & Co. [Average Rating:6.36 Overall Rank:851]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 1986 SdJ winner, and #23 seed, Heimlich & Co.?
35
Ooh. This one is tough. There was a time that I'd've given the nod to Um Reifenbreite, but that game just takes longer than I'm usually willing to devote to one game nowadays.
Ask Me About the Global Geek Photo Album Project (Erik Warnes)
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
06070809
Heimlich is, possibly, the perfect filler game. It's wonderful.
15. Board Game: Zooloretto [Average Rating:7.08 Overall Rank:188] [Average Rating:7.08 Overall Rank:188]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 2007 SdJ winner, and #11 seed, Zooloretto...
54
J W
flag
Avatar
05060708
I think this is a really weak winner. Maybe not the weakest, but...very disappointing, esp. considering the decent field this year.
16. Board Game: Drunter und Drüber [Average Rating:6.42 Overall Rank:899]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 1991 SdJ winner, and #22 seed, Drunter & Drüber?
35
Age discrimination is going to kill this great game, I fear.
Simon Hilsdorf
flag
Avatar
Randy Cox wrote:
Age discrimination is going to kill this great game, I fear.


Looks like age discrimination is a theme on this list - almost all games are paired old - new. While one still can rate from a todays perspective I think it's kind of 'unfair' towards the older games.

When some of the game came out they were innovative or at least new to the broader audience.

Things like hidden characters (Heimlich & Co), Clay-guessing-games (Barbarossa), an abstract game (Focus), crayon railroad games (Dampfross), many vs. one (Scotland Yard) or storytelling (Sherlock Holmes) were definitely something new and cool when they came out back in the days and you didn't have much stuff to compare it with. Nowadays many old mechanics have been succesfully worked into new (better) games...

Anyway, games like Auf Achse, Sagaland, Barbarossa and Drunter & Drüber have been played in my family for several years and proved to be great family games. :)

Simon
Dave VanderArk
flag
Avatar
0405060708
I'm not voting for either of these because:
a) I haven't played Zooloretto
b) I don't care much for Drunter & Druber because every time we play it the kids end up fighting.
Edited Tue Aug 7, 2007 9:29 pm
Joe Huber
Zopper-Alf wrote:
Randy Cox wrote:
Age discrimination is going to kill this great game, I fear.


Looks like age discrimination is a theme on this list - almost all games are paired old - new. While one still can rate from a todays perspective I think it's kind of 'unfair' towards the older games.


I agree, though at least here the lower rated games will have _some_ chance, as all that's needed is a preference, not outrating the newer game with fewer ratings...
Simon Hilsdorf
flag
Avatar
That's absolutely no problem Joe. I don't take this list too serious.
It was more meant as an general comment about how games changed. I played all SdJs except from Niagara and most of them when they came out. They all were definitely good or excellent games compared to the rest of the market and even more compared to your own horizon back then.

It's hard to judge games on what was new back then and not compare them to todays stadards - and why would you even not do that. Today you have the choice over several games with the same theme or similar mechanics...

Anyway, the SdJ was always an easy pick for me or my parents and we definitely enjoyed the games back then and I still enjoy most of them now too.

Simon
17. Board Game: Elfenland [Average Rating:6.83 Overall Rank:318]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 1998 SdJ winner, and #12 seed, Elfenland...
84
J. David Koch
flag
Avatar
thumbsup Have to go with Elfenland here.
Karl
flag
I absolutely love this game, especially with Elfengold. I don't think that I've ever played this game and not had a good time.
18. Board Game: Barbarossa [Average Rating:6.54 Overall Rank:786]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 1988 SdJ winner, and #21 seed, Barbarossa?
26
Yoki Erdtman
flag
Avatar
0708
Since Barbarossa is one of my 8-year old daughter's favorites, so I'll give it the nod. I hate the name and the box though, but the game's neat.
19. Board Game: Niagara [Average Rating:6.66 Overall Rank:443]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 2005 SdJ winner, and #13 seed, Niagara...
58
20. Board Game: Mississippi Queen [Average Rating:6.46 Overall Rank:681]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 1997 SdJ winner, and #20 seed, Mississippi Queen?
77
Karl
flag
I enjoy Mississippi Queen, as The Black Rose, but most of my friends aren't crazy about it.
Ask Me About the Global Geek Photo Album Project (Erik Warnes)
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
06070809
theconcerned wrote:
I enjoy Mississippi Queen, as The Black Rose, but most of my friends aren't crazy about it.


My group doesn't seem to want to give Mississippi Queen the love.
21. Board Game: Hare & Tortoise [Average Rating:6.73 Overall Rank:434]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 1979 SdJ winner, and #14 seed, Hare & Tortoise...
56
Stven Carlberg
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
Hase und Igel has been one of my favorites for years, but I'd rather be looking at a picture of one of the older editions from the era when the game actually did win SdJ and had not yet been watered down to the strength of Kool-Aid by allowing a lettuce to be chewed by the roll of a die from any position in the race except first.
22. Board Game: Scotland Yard [Average Rating:6.54 Overall Rank:581]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 1983 SdJ winner, and #19 seed, Scotland Yard?
76
Huzonfirst
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
050708
Interesting matchup. Two of the more "thinky" games on the list.
James Davis
flag
Avatar
08
A real classic this game. Any parent should have this for their kids. And it still plays great when playing with other adults.
Darryl Boone
flag
Avatar
060708
I've owned this twice and lost it twice. As much as I really enjoy this game, I just can't bring myself to buy it a third time. Everyone I've ever introduced it to strongly dislikes it.

(Hmm, maybe that's why they've gone missing? Sabotage!)
23. Board Game: Hoity Toity [Average Rating:6.66 Overall Rank:461]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 1990 SdJ winner, and #15 seed, Adel Verpflichtet...
73
Huzonfirst
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
050708
I wonder how many votes this one will lose because of the name it's listed as in the database?
J. David Koch
flag
Avatar
thumbsup Adel Verpflichtet
I have always considered Adel Verpflichtet to be THE German Game. It was the first one I remember being played with any regularity (when Avalon Hill produced it) and it got a lot of wargamers I know (now mostly ex-wargamers) to play "lighter" stuff. Quite the pedigree.
Dangit! Suspended Again
flag
Avatar
040506070809
You could call this game Chipped Beef on Toast and I'd still prefer it to almost any other SdJ winner.
24. Board Game: Villa Paletti [Average Rating:6.59 Overall Rank:583]
Shop
Joe Huber
 ...or the 2002 SdJ winner, and #18 seed, Villa Paletti?
46
25. Board Game: Manhattan [Average Rating:6.73 Overall Rank:414]
Shop
Joe Huber
 Do you prefer the 1994 SdJ winner, and #16 seed, Manhattan...

(For those who don't wish to bother looking to the next page unless necessary, the game Manhattan is matched up with is Sherlock Holmes, Consulting Detective.)
59
1 , 2  Next »   | 
16 comments [Hide]
Scott Firestone
flag
Avatar
050708
I'd participate, but there's not one of these pairs where I've played both games.
Huzonfirst
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
050708
Randy Cox wrote:
I just don't see it. Personal tastes aside, I see only one particularly bad game here (Dampfross), and I'm hoping that rules were just changed somewhere along the way (maybe after it won SdJ) which turned it into the quagmire it is today.

All in all, just about every one of these games would not be a problem to sit down and play with any crowd. (Note: haven't played Zooloretto and haven't ever enjoyed any of that designer's games, so there may be two stinkers in here).

I'd go even further. I've never played Dampfross, but since it was elected to the Counter Hall of Fame (well, Railway Rivals, its progenitor, was), I can't believe it to be objectively bad. And I'm no big fan of Zooloretto (it only seemed to be a marginal improvement on Coloretto, a game which is little more than a pleasant filler to me), but the game works and should find a sizable audience. Really, the only possible "bad" SdJ winner I've tried is Niagara, but enough people like that game that I'm willing to believe that I just had a bad session of it. The bar for "not being objectively bad" isn't a terribly high one, but I'd say all these games clear it easily.

Now that's not to say that I play lots of SdJ winners. There's only four of them I'm enthusiastic about (Tikal, Barbarossa, H&T, and T&T) and another half dozen or so I don't mind playing. But I can't say I've ever played one that I thought was bad.
Dangit! Suspended Again
flag
Avatar
040506070809
I think Zooloretto is getting a ridiculous backlash effect, perhaps because of Yspahan's fanbase being a disgruntled, unruly mob. Sure it's only a marginal improvement over Coloretto, but it's a wide margin. The game is fun, purely and simply fun. It's not rocket science, thank God, nor is it Rocketville, doubly thank God!
Jim Payne
flag
An interesting thing to do would be to compare the BGG rankings of the SDJ winners with the BGG ranking of the nominees for the same year. In many cases BGGers think the wrong game won.
Ben Lott
flag
Avatar
070809
What's up! 158 votes on a single entry but the list as a whole only has 29 thumbs? How are we gonna keep this list "Hot" if we don't give it the recommendations? Just my opinion, but I think if you're going to participate by voting you should be recommending the list to others.
Edited Thu Aug 9, 2007 7:27 pm
1 , 2  Next »   | 
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
BoardGameGeek and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.