geek
The Thrifter's Guide to ...... 3M games - Part 2
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
Recommend
34
..and we continue our examination and discussion of what is worthwhile to pick and what we should pass on while thrifting.
Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: thrift [+] [View All]
Posted Wed Sep 12, 2007 8:54 pm
1. Board Game: Thinking Man's Basketball [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
Another flatbox sports game. What makes this one special? It was never published other than prototypes. But one pulled over $1000 on eBay in 2005.

I would say that if you see this one, grab it and then go buy an extra pair of pants, because you probably messed the ones you were wearing. This is some good history to own.
Dan Blum
flag
BGG Admin
0809
It went for a bit over $1400 as I recall. I'm not sure there's more than that one copy known, although I'm no expert (I see one user here owns it, but for all I know he bought the one on eBay).

There was also a Thinking Man's Baseball which existed only in prototype. I think one was auctioned years ago on rec.games.board.marketplace, but I won't swear to it (it might have been Basketball).

3M Germany had a prototype called Profi Fussball - copies may or may not exist.
Hermann Huth
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
070809
Quote:
3M Germany had a prototype called Profi Fussball - copies may or may not exist.

It exists. I´ve seen it.
2. Board Game: Thorns [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
A Pad & Pencil game
David Bohnenberger
flag
Avatar
050608
This is a worthwhile grab for any fan of the band Ween - this was used for the cover of the CD "Quebec".
3. Board Game: Snare [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
Another Pad & Pencil game.
4. Board Game: Point Of Law [Average Rating:4.21 Overall Rank:5232]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
A parlor type game where everyone tries to determine the actual verdict of a legal case. I don't see this one getting played around my house, but I can see where it could be adapted for play on a car trip.

Any other opinions?
Greg Hacker
flag
Avatar
Personally, I don't see this as much fun at all. As an attorney, I could see most of the verdicts from a mile away, which would probably be true for anyone else even moderately involved in a legal profession. Another problem is that a number of the legal principles upon which the verdicts in the cases are based on are now fairly outdated, leading to frustration as players guess a verdict which would be true under more current law, but which is wrong under the 1960's principles of law at issue. On top of that, some of legal issues in the cases are dependent on a state's or localities' particular laws. Because law varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, there is always some confusion (read disagreements/arguments) about whether the verdicts are right or not.
Eschew Obfuscation
flag
Avatar
06070809
Speaking of lawyers-
Why do they bury lawyers 12 feet deep instead of the usual 6 feet deep?

Spoiler (mouseover to reveal):
Greg Hacker
flag
Avatar
berserkley wrote:


As an attorney, can you explain why the Counselor on the cover has a transparent arm? :p


I could, but I'd have to bill you by the hour for the answer!;)

Actually, the syndrome affecting the lawyer on the cover is all too common--after losing their souls upon graduating from law school, many attorneys, their bodies left a lifeless husk, gradually fade away into an incorporeal state of nothingness. :)

Doug "I found 2 copies of 'Outpost' Iverson
flag
As an attorney, I can say its much more like the Lord of the Rings, see the Nazgul circling around the court house.
Tim Thorp
flag
Avatar
040506070809
Dammit people, don't make me laugh in the middle of work! :laugh:
5. Board Game: Mimikri [Average Rating:4.67 Unranked]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
A chess variant with only 2 ratings and 8 owners. Any opinions?
Dan Blum
flag
BGG Admin
0809
I can't comment on how good a game it is - it's chess with concealed pieces (they are wooden cubes with the icon on only one side). However, it's certainly worth picking up for resale - it's not worth a fortune but more than you'll pay at a thrift store. On the other hand, you're not likely to find it at an American thrift store since it was only sold in Germany.
6. Board Game: Sum-Up [Average Rating:5.08 Unranked]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
Very little is available on the gamette. 33 folks own it so we should be able to get some more information or opinions on it.
Tim Thorp
flag
Avatar
040506070809
Whoa! Never seen this one.
Squeeker
flag
Avatar
070809
This one sells for about $15 on ebay.
Hermann Huth
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
070809
From this one also exists a very rare butterbox edition. Included is a die - for whatever reasons.
Scott A. Reed
flag
BGG Admin
Avatar
040506070809
The rules as presented in this one make for a very uninspiring game. Basically, players get a hand of cards, and try to make the highest-valued equation for the round. Played over successive rounds, players begin by building addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division problems. Players rotate their hands so all players have an opportunity with one of the sets of numbers. The game really seems geared at the elementary set, though, since any rational adult should be able to spot the highest-scoring equation within a given set of cards rather readily.
7. Board Game: Thinking Man's Football [Average Rating:4.96 Overall Rank:4689]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
A flatbox sports game. Each player a type of offense & defense. A passing play is effected by wind if it is within certain areas of the field. I owned it, played it, & wasn't impressed.

I would pass if I saw another one. Especially the one currently on eBay with a starting bid of $100. :shake: (some folks)
1
0 comments
Edited Wed Sep 12, 2007 8:42 pm
Subscribe  | Comment
8. Board Game: Stocks & Bonds [Average Rating:5.42 Overall Rank:4527]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
I have picked up a copy of this and passed on at least one a month since then. I have never played it, but I found that they never really pulled much on eBay.

Any opinions on if it is worth a thrift store price?
Angus the Bull
flag
Avatar
05060708
A "sim" type game; it's much like "playing" the real stockmarket. Pretend the projections are right, spend your money and let lady luck take you for a ride.

You could call it a dicefest even though there's only 2d6

My sister's kids enjoy it as a "party" game.
Edited Wed Sep 12, 2007 9:12 pm
Stephen Smith
flag
Avatar
0506
Quote:
A "sim" type game; it's much like "playing" the real stockmarket. Pretend the projections are right, spend your money and let lady luck take you for a ride.

You could call it a dicefest even though there's only 2d6

One of the guys we played this with in college always won. If he was cheating, he was darn good at it. Maybe he is a financial wizard or something.
Tim Thorp
flag
Avatar
040506070809
I played this game a long time ago. I recall it was alot of fun, but not the deepest game out there. Probably worth grabbing if complete and in nice shape.
Christian Killoran
flag
Avatar
I recently found myself NEEDING another copy of this game and thought, "no big deal...I'll just grab one at the thrift store." To my disappointment, none of the local thrifts or used game shops has one! Now I have to figure out a way for my old copy to be played two times simultaneously. This is a great game for my economics class-easy to teach, fun for the students, and a good intro to the basics of personal investing.
Marshall
flag
0506070809
OK, this game may not be the most exciting 3M game out of the box. But I have worked on rules for short selling, junk bonds, buy/sell options, variable interest rates, etc. I like the game in general because downtime is minimized by the parallel play - rather than each player taking a turn in serial fashion (like Monopoly).
9. Board Game: Octrix [Average Rating:5.53 Unranked]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
A gamette card game where everyone knows what everyone else has in their hand. Sounds like this could lead to huge AP. Some commenst compare this to Bridge.

Pass or Pick up?
Dan Blum
flag
BGG Admin
0809
No idea on gameplay, and I don't think the gamette version is worth all that much, but if you see the butterdish version, definitely pick it up. I believe only one copy is known and that sold for $800.
Michael Plach
flag
Avatar
:shake:As I already said, I was an enthusiastic US-ebayer from overseas the 14 months back or so.
During this time span I found two butterdish OCTRIX on offer. The first one was complete and fetched around 450 $, the second one I tried myself, not complete (the game,not me...), but went for around 350 $ also. Just sit and wait...
10. Board Game: Phlounder [Average Rating:5.23 Overall Rank:4493]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
Several of the 3M games were variations of parlor games (word games, bridge, chess, numbers games) and this one is no different. It does have an interesting mechanic of the letters being pushed through a track on the board. Like some word games, speed counts.

This one was also published in a first edition 'big box' format. That would be the only version that could be considered ebait.


Pass or grab?
3 comments [Hide]
Edited Wed Sep 12, 2007 8:13 pm
Subscribe  | Comment
Michael Plach
flag
Avatar
:what:There are mainly two reasons to grab two versions of this game: The fat box for the large wooden tiles which can replace missing ones in the world map ACQUIRE, and the later edition, also with wooden tiles, to replace the ones in ACQUIRE standard box with wooden tiles.
You have to do a little erasing and handpainting, though...
Ah, and the bell is a nice gimmick also, you can use it for PIT or in a chess match to drive your opponent crazy or whatever...

Unfortunately both versions don't fetch high prices on ebay, even the last 2 or 3 fat boxes stayed below 10 $.
Not being a thrifter, this is one of my few "finds." Back a zillion years ago, I saw this in a remainder bin at a downtown drug store (in Clemson SC). Stuff they had in the back that never sold and still had the original price tag and shrink wrap on it. I think it was either $1.95 or $2.95.

Speaking of which... why did so many drug stores have these games back in the day? Another drug store (in Greer, SC) used to have wargames and 3M games and AH games and Parker Bros games. Someone told us about it back 20 years ago and we went to purchase gobs of games like SPI monster games and 3M games. I even got Landslide out of it. :)
Zack Stockdale
flag
Avatar
0708
Its not a bad game but a ton of luck. I played a couple rounds with my wife and in-laws, there was a lot of luck involved, you draw 6 tiles and try and make a 4-6 letter word by drawing new tiles and replacing the old ones. However, if you draw the right tiles originally you win immediately, which can be annoying. Plus the whole track thing doesn't work very well and can be just frustrating. However, if you like word games and you found this cheap I would say pick up.
11. Board Game: Neo Chess [Average Rating:5.93 Unranked]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
Yup, it's chess again, but this one sounds interesting since any captured piece defects to the other side.

Is it worth a thrift store price?
Dan Blum
flag
BGG Admin
0809
For play purposes, sure, as it's probably an interesting variant (known popularly as "Chessgi"). I have the Abacus set (Mad Mate) myself. It does OK on the resale market. There are two versions which are somewhat different in size, I don't recall which is more valuable, if there is even any difference.
Pete Border
flag
Japanese chess, aka "Shogi" has a rule like that. It makes for some interesting games....
12. Board Game: Quinto [Average Rating:5.84 Overall Rank:3608]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
A numbers version of Scrabble that I have passed on about six times. What is everyone else's opinion?
Dave Lartigue
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
05060708
Nothing to write home about, but not bad.
Michael Plach
flag
Avatar
:)The first edition of this one also has wooden tiles, the smallest ones ever produced for a 3M game.
Box colour is light red contrary to the green one with plastic pieces.
If the advertising is right, the wooden version fetches around 40 $.
Again, if you know what you are looking for, you can get some for below 10 $.

As a game, for me it's a keeper, my kind of stuff with tile laying and a little calculating for optimizing your results.
13. Board Game: Oh-Wah-Ree [Average Rating:5.80 Overall Rank:3432]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
A bookshelf version of Mancala that allows for 4 players. Other than picking it up for the artwork, I would probably pass. I had one and gave it away.

Anyone else have a different opinion?
Tim Taylor
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
05060708


I got this when it was new and think this game has a few things going for it.

Contains several interesting variations on Mancala. Has a nice faux marble plastic gameboard. The version I got came with lots of polished pebbles which adds to the ambience of this game.

This one is a keeper in my collection.
Brad Miller
flag
Avatar
040506070809
Agreed. A decent game. I play with my kids.
Nate Sandall
flag
Avatar
0405060708
Look for the larger first edition big box.
14. Board Game: Thinking Man's Golf [Average Rating:5.79 Overall Rank:3530]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
A flatbox version of Challenge at Pebble Beach. I'm not big on golf games and I don't see a value here, even thrift value.

Anyone else?
Angus the Bull
flag
Avatar
05060708
I'll sit down to a solitaire game of this once every few months. Some strategy and a fair amount luck combine to make this enjoyable for a game on occasion if you don't mind swearing at the dice for hooking you into the rough. I've got a dollar's worth of enjoyment back out of mine so I felt it was worth it.
15. Board Game: Nab [Average Rating:4.00 Unranked]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
3M published several 'paper games' that were basically a preprinted pad. These seem to be fairly rare since I don't see a pad of paper surviving to get to a thrift store of even get THROUGH a thrift store.

Any opinions?
Frank Pergand
flag
Avatar
08
It would be interesting to see whether the "play this with your grandparents" spin worked better or worse than the "play this with a sexy girl" tactic employed by most of the other 3M paper game cover art.
16. Board Game: Mr. Who? [Average Rating:5.40 Unranked]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
Here's one that I had never heard of. It's published in a 'crackerbox' format which 3M hardly used. It sounds like an interesting deduction game and it MIGHT be worth something on eBay, if there were any there.

I would grab this one if spotted.
Dan Blum
flag
BGG Admin
0809
It's an interesting idea for a deduction game, and isn't bad in practice, although nothing to seek out for the gameplay.

Not sure how you're searching on eBay - at least one was actually sold there quite recently. It did not go for nearly as much as it should considering it was still sealed - eBay prices for oddball items can vary a lot depending on how much the seller advertises.
Michael Plach
flag
Avatar
:soblue:I did bid for the aforementioned sealed version also. Unfortunately my ebay-bank-account was emptied the week before, so my funds were really exhausted.
The sealed version went for 28 $ excl. postage 5 days ago, because the innocent seller advertised it not with the magical "3M" in all his advertising text !
Edited Sun Oct 28, 2007 11:35 pm
17. Board Game: Plasm [Average Rating:6.00 Unranked]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
Another pad & pencil format game.
18. Board Game: Regatta [Average Rating:6.02 Overall Rank:2033]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
A bookcase sports game about sailing. This one has a fairly large distribution (compared to some others) with about 400 owners and nearly 200 ratings.

I would grab this one if I see it.
1
Simon Hunt
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
040506070809
Awesome game!
Brad Miller
flag
Avatar
040506070809
Rules were way incomplete, (who moves first each turn?), and I like the flat-box version better than the bookcase ones. Also, the wind shifts are far too random. But it's a pretty good game nonetheless.
Frank Pergand
flag
Avatar
08
Nice metal boats, that tilt as an intergral part of the game.

Never got to play.:(

Sold for about $25 on Ebay.
Aaron Sapp
flag
0708
This also comes in a flat box version. It was one of the first games that I really sought out on eBay after playing.
19. Board Game: Ploy [Average Rating:6.12 Overall Rank:2220]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
Up front, I would put this one in my thrift store cart. The 'Spock' cover, the 'future' furniture on the back, and some very good gameplay makes this one a keeper. Avalon Hill thought so as well. I haad one years ago and sold it. I'm keeping the next one I find.

It doesn't pull much on eBay, but for about $4 I think that it is worth it.
1
3 comments [Hide]
Edited Wed Sep 12, 2007 8:17 pm
Subscribe  | Comment
Stephen Smith
flag
Avatar
0506
It's been about three years since I last checked, but back then, this one routinely went in the $30-40's range.
Lacey's Grandpa
flag
Avatar
05060708
A truly unique abstract with excellent plastic components that should last many lifetimes...the pieces are of a substance that rivals the hardness of tooth enamel. Both this game and Twixt don't get near enough table-time to suit me.

Gg
Cyriel
flag
Avatar
Just thrifted one today. The components are very nice indeed! Love that funky sixties artwork too :cool:
20. Board Game: Tryce [Average Rating:5.95 Unranked]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
An odd gamette that has normal playing cards with letters on them. Players can make 'runs', 'books', or 'words' so it is a word game & a card game. This one also came in a butterdish version.



I might nab this one. But I would positively grab the butterdish.
4 comments [Hide]
Edited Wed Sep 12, 2007 8:49 pm
Subscribe  | Comment
Nate Sandall
flag
Avatar
0405060708
How much is the butterbox version worth? I found one thrifting this summer. The box is in rough shape but the rest of it is in great shape. I knew it was worth grabbing but I don't have any idea how worthwhile.
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
The butterdishes alwyas go for more just because they are butterdishes. I sold one butterdish (not this one) for about $50, if I recall.
Tim Koffley
flag
Avatar
040506070809
The non-butterdish can fetch upwards of $30 for good condition but the market for it is wildly random, i.e. the people who want it only pop up once in a while.
Michael Plach
flag
Avatar
:surprise:the past butterdishes I watched in ebay didn't rise over the 30 $ mark.
There was a first edition of the butterbox, a little larger than the one shown in the picture, with completely different top box design. If this is correctly advertised, it will bring for sure $$ in the 3-digit range into your coffers...
21. Board Game: Mr. President [Average Rating:6.41 Overall Rank:1919]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
A bookshelf game with a LOT of input here. 96 ratings, 242 owners, 6+ rating. This one seems to be well receieved. It doesn't appear to pull much on eBay.

I would pick it up. Anyone else?
Joe Huber
The 1965 version isn't particularly common and doesn't show up so often on Ebay; when identified as the 1965 edition (either variety), it earns a premium.

Very enjoyable two player game, however, and well worth buying to play.
Dan Blum
flag
BGG Admin
0809
To expand on Joe's comment a bit - the 1965/1966 version is a completely different game from the 1967/1971 version. The latter is the one people like.

The 1965/6 version is more or less a trick-taking game, and is not worth getting for the gameplay. It is certainly worth picking up for resale. The 1965 version has a chalkboard for scoring, the 1966 version has a board covered with dials for scoring. They have the same cover art as the later versions, but the boxes are not dark red - one is tan and one is a light brownish-red.
Michael Plach
flag
Avatar
:DAgain I only can encourage everyone to invest a little effort in ebay if you know what you are looking for.
I got the very first edition with the chalkboard 4 months ago in mint condition with the cards still shrinkwrapped.
The game sat in the middle of the "Buy-it-now" compartment for 19 $.

I like this light trick taking version, fast play and suitable for younger children.
the 1967 version I played long way back, but remember it a very good game to my liking. Have to put this on the table once more...
22. Board Game: Monad [Average Rating:6.47 Overall Rank:2152]
Jonah Hex - 08/06/2010. I can't wait!
flag
Avatar
050708
Another submission in the Gamette/butterdish format. Sid Sackson design of a card game. It has a respectable 6+ rating so I would pick this one up.
4 comments [Hide]
Edited Wed Sep 12, 2007 7:51 pm
Subscribe  | Comment
Don Weed
flag
Avatar
0506070809
Indeed pick this one up. It has commonalities with both rummy (collecting sets) and a lot of newer Euros where you cumulatively build up to higher and higher levels. Had great fun with this in my younger years.
Ask Me About the Global Geek Photo Album Project (Erik Warnes)
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
06070809
They spelled Nomad wrong.
Frank Cunliffe
flag
unixrevolution wrote:
They spelled Nomad wrong.


Thus Nomad would want to destroy all copies of Monad.

(There was an epidose of Classic Star Trek titled "The Changeling" in which a robot named "Nomad" sought to destroy all instances of imperfection. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nomad_(Star_Trek) )