geek
Grand Old Games (Part 1): Rare and Well Done
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
Recommend
209
I am fairly new to BGG but I have been a gamer most of my life and a collector for quite a while. My collection is focused on Wargames and Strategy games from the 1880s to 1950 and I now have over 80 games from that period.

I have slowly been adding them to the BGG database and figured I'd pause every so often and share the new additions via a Geeklist. It's an interesting piece of gaming history.

While the games are all fairly rare they also represent a broad range of quality of presentation and depth of play. The first set I wanted to get out to folks is probably my most rare, and most interesting.

The presentation (map and/or playing pieces) really sets this group apart from the rest of my collection.

I hope you enjoy them....

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: obscure_games [+] wargaming [+] [View All]
Posted Tue Nov 13, 2007 12:24 pm
1. Board Game: Waterloo [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
The first two games are appetizers. Waterloo (1895) and the following game (Kriegspiel Junior) are the only two games on the list that aren't complete (no rules or pieces) but the map presentations are amazing.

Waterloo's map is lacquered onto a wooden board 14"x21" that acts as the top of the game box. The game is over 100 years old and the board still has a vibrant color and is very playable...

I have a line on the rules and hope to have details on game play in the near future.
8
4 comments [Hide]
Edited Tue Nov 13, 2007 4:53 am
Subscribe  | Comment
Eric Feifer
flag
Did it strike anyone else odd that there is no named Waterloo spot on the board, yet Quatre Bras is named?
Barry Kendall
flag
Game Designer
It appears that the field of Waterloo is distinguished by green coloration and by the fact that it is the final defensive position before Brussels can be occupied--just as Ligny is depicted as the approach to Namur.

Since Waterloo represented Wellington's final stand before Brussels, this makes sense, particularly since Napoleon's strategic goal was not clear at the outset of the campaign. It might be inferred that a key aspect of the game involved capture of either Namur or Brussels, using a French axis of advance that could go either way but hinged on capture of the key crossroads of Quatre Bras in the center of the board.

I wonder if the names provided on the board are to indicate the locations the designer most wanted to emphasize in carrying out his design goals.

It would be fascinating to unearth more about this game; it seems like the grandfather of Tom Dalgliesh's "Napoleon."
Pee di Moor
flag
Avatar
0809
Mind sharing with with us how/where/when you obtained these early games?
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
I was just lucky, I didn't know what I had when I found the board for Kriegspiel Junior and it clued me in to the presence of other old games.

I found it on eBay listed as a board for an old game... When I received it in the mail I realized how old it was and noticed the notation on the bottom of the map. Doing some research I found that there were quite a few war/strategy games by PB and MB during the late 1800s and early 1900s but I didn't know what they looked like, no pictures anywhere.

When I saw the Waterloo map at auction I almost had a cow! I really didn't know that PB had done other similar games. This board was in better shape but obviously earlier since it didn't have any notations except for a "Pat. Pending" note at the bottom. When I got it in the mail I was amazed to find a full box with the map as the top of the box. It even has a slot for game pieces. Great stuff.
1
Edited Wed Nov 14, 2007 11:50 am
2. Board Game: Kriegspiel Junior [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
Kriegspiel Junior (1915) is larger than Waterloo (16"x22") and again the version I have is just the map lacquered on a board (no box, rules or pieces).

The map is more detailed than Waterloo with more points, the addition of fortresses, a river and with the same clarity and detail that shows so well on the Waterloo map.

I would love to know how this game plays....

8
3 comments [Hide]
Edited Tue Nov 13, 2007 4:54 am
Subscribe  | Comment
David Bohnenberger
flag
Avatar
050608
Remarkably beautiful. Thanks.
Eric Feifer
flag
And Parker Brothers no less!
Mark
flag
Avatar
06070809

So one could infer they use the same ruleset and format. Imagine the pieces are similar too.
3. Board Game: War Tactics/Can Britain Be Invaded [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
The last of the very early games, War Tactics - Can Britain be Invaded (~1917) is special because of of what it brings to the player at such an early stage in strategy/war gaming.

The detailed map, multiple unit types with different abilities and special rules make for an extremely advanced game for its day.

The rules allow for amphibious invasions and bombing raids in a Grand Strategy game created in or around 1915. An amazing accomplishment.

8
0 comments
Edited Tue Nov 13, 2007 12:16 pm
Subscribe  | Comment
4. Board Game: Sturmpioniere [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
The rest of the games are from the WWII era and I thought I'd bookend this group with my favorites.

Strumpionere (late 1930s) is one of the tops of my list because of the components. The game supplies 4 identical triangular maps that form a square game board when put together. The goal is a wooden bunker that sits on the spot where all four maps come together.

The pieces are painted flats of German Pioneers with different implements and the detail of each is excellent. The game play is simple but with the pieces and the map its really special.

I have only seen one copy of this in all my years of collecting. A spectacular box and game set.
9
3 comments [Hide]
Edited Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:48 am
Subscribe  | Comment
Barry Kendall
flag
Game Designer
Wow, that is an absolutely amazing find. I wonder if there is anyone in Germany who could provide information on the development of German popular-market wargames from this era.
Thomas P. Felder
flag
Avatar
05060708
Such information would be from an academic point of view most certainly, as most germans try not to get associated with being interested in this particular period of our history... And those who are have probably other motives then just playing games, if I might add.

Anyway, maybe there is somewhere a paper on this on some obscure university's home page! :-)
However I would guess that most of the games (if there have been any) have been destroyed either in war or post war due to "Entnazifizierungs" activities.
Edited Wed Nov 14, 2007 4:32 pm
GRRrrRRrr! ☞
flag
Avatar
0708
I remember an article in the Spielbox magazine about war games from the early 20th century. But I think i threw that away the last time we moved apartments. Maybe I can check and tell you more later.

Edit: Yeah, I remembered correctly. In Spielbox 1 and Spielbox 2 from 2005 there was an article about WWI / WWII games. You can still order them, but - of course - it is in German.
Edited Thu Nov 15, 2007 11:27 am
5. Board Game: Empires [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
Empires (1940) is a true Grand Strategy game. Conquer the world one colony at a time. Even though its a point to point movement game, it's a definite forerunner of Risk in terms of game play mechanics. Key elements include:

* Collecting territories on the map to build an Empire
* Collect resources from the territories which are turned in 3:1 for armaments (a bonus is gained for having all territories in a region)
* Defeat the other players in wars using the armaments to claim territories from them

Not sure if the creators of Risk every saw this game but it sure has some similarities.

10
1 comment [Hide]
Edited Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:51 am
Subscribe  | Comment
Andrew MacLeod
flag
How very, very strange, that in this 1940 game, all of the major powers are involved.....except Germany! Could someone please explain THAt to me?!
6. Board Game: Battle at Sea - The new game of National Defense [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
Battle at Sea (1940) has it all, a roll up vinyl map, metal miniatures, destroyers that can lay smoke screens, cool dice and a log book of ships.

Players move along a path on the map attacking enemy ships when in gunnery range using the special embossed dice to roll hits. The victor is the one that sunk the most tonnage.

I have only ever seen this game one time and while the map is getting a bit rough around the edges (its was rolled up for 60 years) its still one of the most compelling pieces in my collection.
14
3 comments [Hide]
Edited Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:55 am
Subscribe  | Comment
Rob Nutt
flag
Avatar
0708
What a beaut. Love the look of this thing.
Barry Kendall
flag
Game Designer
If I ever spot this box in an antique mall, I'm afraid I might have a heart attack. Boy is that cool.
Seth Owen
flag
Avatar
08
That is an absolutely amazing game
7. Board Game: GHQ [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
GHQ (1940) is simple but like all interesting games its full of choices. The pieces and game map are much more modern than the usual 1940 games.

The map is bright, multicolored and very detailed. The pieces are wooden with different shapes for armor, motorized and infantry corps and they all have a National Flag attached... Each unit type has a different movement and defense with support being key.

Very playable, even now.
10
3 comments [Hide]
Edited Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:59 am
Subscribe  | Comment
Barry Kendall
flag
Game Designer
My gosh, this looks like it could be reissued and be a hit today. Just fascinating. I'd love to see a piece compendium and rules summary to try and home-make one.
John Kula
flag
Avatar
0809
Fascinating. It probably isn't related to the game of the same name desinged/invented by Kurt Vonnegut. Or is it?
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
This GHQ game was published in England in 1940 by Waddingtons, before we were in the war and before Vonnegut went overseas. From what I have been able to find Vonnegut send his GHQ to Saalfield Publishing Co. in Ohio. There was a GHQ done in the USA in the 40s (I have a copy, it was published by All-Fair) but its simply a repacking of another game they made called Battle. I don't think Vonnegut was involved.
8. Board Game: Diplomacy [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
A favorite of mine based on the pieces, the map and the background.

Diplomacy came out in 1939 and after the Germans attacked Poland people wouldn't buy a game with the Nazi Flag on the gameboard. The makers began including an alternate set of Russian and German Flags to replace the offending one on the game board (see the additional picture I included in the Diplomacy record of the database).

Again this game has a lot of choices based on the map board, playing pieces and the addition of special cards to the basic game play. It's all about collecting territories to grow your empire through diplomatic means.
6
0 comments
Edited Tue Nov 13, 2007 6:00 am
Subscribe  | Comment
9. Board Game: Dog Fight [Average Rating:8.00 Unranked]
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
Dog-Fight (1942) - gotta love a game that requires you to set up the board in wooden holders so that it stands erect in the form of a triangle and supports the game's metal planes in little slits on the mapboard (check out the picture under the game's image section).

Dog-Fight has miniature fighters, bombers and Anti-Aircraft weapons and is effective in giving the feel of flying a squadron even if it isn't quite true 3 D.

Not as rare as some of the games in my collection, its presentation easily puts it in the top tier.
8
2 comments [Hide]
Edited Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:31 am
Subscribe  | Comment
Rob Nutt
flag
Avatar
0708
Novel idea.
Fraser
flag
BGG Admin
Game Designer
Avatar
040506070809
Dog-Fight "An aerial combat game", they were much more honest in their advertising back then. These days it would be "the aerial combat game"
10. Board Game: Bombers Aloft [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
Bomber's Aloft (1941) is another bombing game that has a unique way of presenting the game pieces. Each plane is placed nose first in the appropriate elevation slot of a metal holder (elevation is determined at the beginning and changes during game play). The players move around a circle bombing as many targets as possible and getting shot at by AA fire.

The rules say that up to 7 players can play the game in less than 30 minutes. I haven't tried that yet.
6
0 comments
Edited Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:32 am
Subscribe  | Comment
11. Board Game: Dictator [Average Rating:0.00 Unranked]
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
For many collectors Dictator (1939) is the ultimate game. It includes over half a pound of lead miniatures and has a great presentation in terms of components. The lead battleships, planes, subs, and aviators are easily broken so its hard to find the game in one piece...

The game play was fairly deep for its time with cards (coup and revolt) affecting game play as well as a map that was timely including areas that were key in the events of the period.

The game play mechanism is simple but effective (movement around a game circle with spaces that add or take away armaments, cards or money). The goal is to gather resources via conquest of the 3 colonies on the map.

Dictator is the last game of my first Geeklist and hopefully you find this small part of the history of strategy and wargames as interesting as I do. If you have any questions about the games let me know.

I hope to have another group in the database shortly with a focus on things like second tier publishers (Corey games, E.E. Fairchild, and All-Fair Games). I also have a fair number of games produced in Germany (both before and during WWII) that I will be adding.
8
1 comment [Hide]
Edited Tue Nov 13, 2007 5:30 am
Subscribe  | Comment
Dan Cermak
flag
Avatar
07
I added a couple more shots of Dictator to give a better idea of the contents and detail of the game.



The cards (Coup & Revolt) show back and front, side by side, so you can see what kinds of game play they provide.
21 comments [Hide]
David Bohnenberger
flag
Avatar
050608
Amazing list.
Dylan Kirk 郭迪伦
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
Bloody marvellous. The first geeklist on which I regret I have but one thumb to give.
Rick Byrens
flag
050708
It's rare that a geek list nowadays can surprise or delight, but this does both. Congrats on your fine collection!! Truly amazing...I am so jealous!
G Quinn
flag
Unbelievable! I've been a wargamer for 40 years and almost everything you've uncovered here is a revelation to me. I would pay a lot of money for a book compiling these gems, with some fold out maps and cardboard counters. No, I guess that's out of the question. Still, I'll haunt antique shops with these lists in mind. Thanks for the great, great research.
John Kovacs
flag
Avatar
A very interesting list of games that I have never heard of before. How enlightening it is to learn that wargames have been around for a lot longer than we thought. Makes you wonder how many more were out there, printed by obscure companies or self-published, that have vanished into the mists of time. I'm sure you are taking extra care in preserving these rare titles - keep up the good work.
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
BoardGameGeek and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.