geek
Hot Games
Agricola
Conflict of Heroes: Awakening the Bear! - Russia 1941-1942
World of Warcraft: the Adventure Game
Gaslight
Settlers of Catan, The
Keltis
Race for the Galaxy
Pandemic
Ghost Stories
Puerto Rico
Arkham Horror
Risk
Power Grid
Stone Age
Twilight Struggle
Warriors of God
Last Night on Earth: The Zombie Game
A Touch of Evil, The Supernatural Game
Through the Ages: A Story of Civilization
StarCraft: The Board Game
Carcassonne
Tigris & Euphrates
Descent: Journeys in the Dark
Ticket to Ride
BattleLore
War of the Ring
Caylus
Age of Empires III: The Age of Discovery
Wealth of Nations
Tribune: Primus Inter Pares
Twilight Imperium 3rd Edition
Brass
Bang!
Arkham Horror - Kingsport Horror Expansion
Arkham Horror - The Black Goat of the Woods Expansion
Glory to Rome
Acquire
El Grande
Galactic Emperor
Blackbeard
Pillars of the Earth, The
Race for the Galaxy: The Gathering Storm
Lost Cities
Néfertiti
Descent: The Road to Legend
Scrabble
Manoeuvre
Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage
Tide of Iron
Ice Flow
Card driven wargames
Brian Morris
flag
Avatar
05060708
Recommend
116
It was in 1994 that one of the wargame hobby's greatest innovations was created with the release of the game We The People by Mark Herman. It was the card driven wargame system.

The problem before We The People was how to include important historical events in a game that had a major effect on the conflict at the time without making it to linear? For example, the Emancipation Proclamation had a major effect in the American Civil War by allowing the creation of Black regiments, but how to include that in the game without saying it takes effect on an exact game turn and thus the players knowing and playing the game with that in mind. By including that as a card that can be played as an event, the event itself can be included in the game without being linier. So players never know when that event will occur or even if it will.

This system has now been used in a great number of different games in many different historical conflicts. From the American Civil War to WW I, Ancient Rome to the American Revolution. These card driven wargames are now some of the most popular wargames in the hobby and so I thought it might be fun to take a closer look at some of these card driven wargames and for people to chime in on what they like and don't like about this system.

Also I've noticed on the forum and on geeklists we often see people asking questions about the card driven games. What games are card driven, which are the best ones and so on. I figured it might be useful for some of those looking at the card driven games to have them all lined up so they can see what they have to choose from and hear what others have to say on them as well. Sort of like a new car lot but with games instead of automobiles.
Your Tags: View |
Popular Tags: [View All]
Posted On: 2005-08-23 13:46:02
Edited On: 2005-08-23 13:46:02

1 , 2  Next »  

1. We the People [Average Rating:7.58 Overall Rank:138]
Brian Morris
flag
Avatar
05060708
The very first game of this type was the Avalon Hill classic We The People. Rather a hard game to find now and expensive when you do as it's now out of print thanks to Hasbro's hording of certain older Avalon Hill titles. A classic I should say now but I remember when the game first came out and was looked at with skepticism by folks including myself.

1
6 Comments [Hide]
Posted On: 2005-08-23 13:46:02
Comment
Brad Miller
flag
Avatar
0405060708
I think this may be my favorite game of all time. Yes, sometimes it can have an anti-climatic feel, when the War ends is coming and you have a crap hand, but the in-game tension of not knowing what the other player can do, and looking for the best way to play the hand you are dealt, and the neat "Euro-ish" concept of the Political control and isolation are exquisite. Not to mention is relatively light as wargames go, and easily playable in an evening...
Nick Stellato
flag
Avatar
04
I agree with everything Brad says. This game is a winner. Brad also plays very well and has whooped up on me a number of times. In fact, I feel like challenging him again since I've got some spare time.
Gregory Smith
flag
Avatar
04050607
Except for the sad fact that this is out of print, this game is a good entry point for new wargamers interested in card driven wargames. The only thing I an ambivalent about regarding this game is the battle card system for resolving combat. I sure wish I owned the expansion.
Mattias Elfström
flag
Avatar
I have this game and the expansion. It is a truly great game both for introducing newcomers and for more serious play when you don't have a lot of time.
Ian Cooper
flag
Avatar
I still think this is the best of the card-driven wargames simply because of the balance between ease of play and historical realism. Basically I can pick this up even after years and get started within half an hour - I can't say that about any other wargame that I've played.

I still own this game - it's one of my 'most played' games. I wish the later card-driven games had kept to its simple rule format rather than making games in the genre progressively more complex. I'd have loved to have played a WW1 game with between 5 and 10 rules pages rather than Paths of Glory. Ditto for Wilderness War.
2. For the People [Average Rating:7.46 Overall Rank:234]
Brian Morris
flag
Avatar
05060708
The second game by Mark Herman using his card system and some would say one of the best games to use it. This game was my actual introduction to this system and being a civil war buff, it has turned into one of my favorite games. First released by Avalon Hill, this game was improved and then rereleased under the banner of GMT where it went out of print and then like it's predecessor became extremely pricey and hard to find. It's currently on the GMT P500 list waiting for a reprint.

This card driven system while created and first used under Avalon Hill has become a mainstay of GMT games. Used not just by Mark Herman but also designers such as Richard Berg, Wray Ferrell, Mark Simonitch and Ted Raicer

1 Comment [Hide]
Posted On: 2005-08-23 13:46:02
Comment
Mattias Elfström
flag
Avatar
I have the AH version of this game and like it although I don't think it is as elegant as WtP above.
3. Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage [Average Rating:8.14 Overall Rank:14]
Brian Morris
flag
Avatar
05060708
Like it's predecessor We The People, this game is now in the hands of Hasbro and in mint condition will cost you...well a mint.

This game for me has one of the coolest looking mapboards of any of the games on this list. It just has a wonderful look and feel to it.

7 Comments [Hide]
Posted On: 2005-08-23 13:46:02
Comment
Zippadeedoodah
flag
Avatar
07
Totally concur on this one. It's a brilliant game that not only looks good, but through the strategy cards gives a somewhat randomized but nonetheless historic feel to the game. One of my all-time favourites that I never regretted buying nearly 10 years ago.
David Seddon
flag
Avatar
05060708
The game is not hyped, as I discovered upon playing it. It really is as good as it's legend...and I need say no more than that, except that it is easier to get a fair grip on than some of the games that followed it.
Gregory Smith
flag
Avatar
04050607
This is currently my favorite card driven game (despite the fact it uses the battle card system for resolving battles, of which I am not so fond). This is an exciting and dynamic game to play. It provides a good historical "feel" for the situation faced by each side. It is absolutely worth it's current ebay price, if you like the card driven wargames. Luckily I got mine long before the prices became what they are. No it's not for sale. :-)
Mattias Elfström
flag