Ozvortex wrote:
My wife was complaining of exactly the same scenario the other night after I got BattleLore for Xmas!
Was she complaining more about having to read through the 80-page Battlelore rule booklet OR because she as winner didn't get properly rewarded with an appealing form of tribute afterwards?

If it was indeed the latter, then you really do need to incentive gameplay with some more appealing spoils of victory. Tribute can be offered in many different forms, including the most banal. For example, you could propoose that the loser must make up the bed the next morning.
Hopefully, after having waged a successful battle, you as victor won't have to so much as duck and cover as much as duck under the covers to dictate some win-win terms of surrender.