Scott Key
United States
Knoxville
Tennessee
-
I’ve now played four scenarios of this game (1, 2, 4 & 5) and thoroughly enjoyed each one. It is a super-fast, simple and fun game that brings tactics to the front while managing to neatly preserve the concerns of trench raiding.
Components
The game plays in around 15 to 30 minutes with a small number of components on a small (11x17) game map. The game is Definitely in the micro-game tradition but with better components. The game uses nicely sized ¾” pieces that have good graphics representing Hand-to-hand, grenadier, rifle, LMG and MG units. Each of these units represents anything from a team of 2 men to a squad of 10 depending on the scenario and the quality of the men. All information is conveyed very well and I did not feel like I had any real confusion about any rules. The counters are mounted and die-cut but aren’t coated. The map is printed on heavy card-stock in full color. Most information you need to play the game is reproduced on the Map itself. The design of the map and its functionality as a component in a wargame is perfect.
Play
What I like is how I am focusing on tactics the whole time. In my first game the Germans are raiding and attempting to eliminate two Lewis Gun posts. The raiders chose a very straightforward tactic, using one unit of grenadiers to block reinforcements to the isolated LMG post. This worked but the Germans didn’t win because they were still on the board at games end. In ToV you get many of your VP (usually around ½) from exiting raider units back in to No Man’s Land (before the box barrage lifts). I have found that this aspect of the game needs to be given as much attention as any other tactical consideration. When in the third game the Canadians quickly eliminated a German Maxim position, focused the remaining German units’ efforts on denying an easy exit to the raiders who quickly ran out of options for gaining the VPs they needed to win. They could only attempt to kill the last Maxim, which was too well protected in its fortified position and survived repeated grenade attacks.
So, based on the four solo-games I’ve played so far, I would give this game a glowing recommendation. Play is quick so you may wish to play multiple scenarios in a session.
The game designer writes that there should be a expansion kit out in the near future. It will feature leaders, Engineers, flamethrowers and more scenarios. I will buy it the minute it is released. My wish is for a myriad of counter-sheets to be released to allow for scenarios in other theaters and also for some additional types of maps that would allow scenarios in No Man’s land and against other fortifications (concrete emplacements, fortified shell-hole complexes, underground French forts).
yours,
Scott Pasha
-
Pelle Nilsson
Sweden
Linköping
-
Thanks Scott for taking the time to write that aar/review, and I'm obviously happy that you liked the game.
Still some things to do on the expansion before playtesting...
-
-
Thanks for the review.
I just ordered this ToV + others.
I will wait for the expansionssssssssssssssss to come.
My Question : Has this game anything to see with the antic "TrenchFoot" ?
-
Pelle Nilsson
Sweden
Linköping
-
Thank you, Taladro!
Any similarities to Trench Foot is purely by accident. I don't know anything about that game more than what can be seen in a few photos here on the geek.
-
Scott Key
United States
Knoxville
Tennessee
-
I'm old enough to have got Trenchfoot when it came out and this game is totally different. Trenchfoot is a 1:1 scale with preplotted move system, which, of course, ToV is not. No offense to Frank Chadwick but ToV is way better.
SP
-
Jonan Jello
United States
the enclave known as Newark
California
Cedar Waxwing & Western Scrub Jay
-
So the game's decent as a solo affair?
I'm edging closer and closer to picking this up along with Zulus.
If I can ignore the high cost of shipping, I may grab some games.
-
|
|
