User Profile for JohnnyDollar
Yours Truly,
United States
North Carolina
flag msg tools
There must have been a moment at the beginning, where we could have said no. Somehow we missed it. Well, we'll know better next time.
Previous Avatars I Have Used:

Recently Played Games:

NOTE about my ratings:
I use tenths: X.5 is solid, X.2 is borderline the previous lower rating, X.8 is borderline the next higher rating.
However, because of this, the BGG graph is skewed high:
What it shows as my 10s are actually all my 10s and all my 9s (since my 9s are all 9.2 or 9.5 or 9.8).
What it shows as my 9s are actually all my 8s.
What it shows as my 8s are actually all my 7s.
And so on.

My username is from an Old Time Radio show I love, Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar. It's about a freelance insurance investigator, "the man with the action-packed expense account." (It's a lot more fun than it sounds!)

I love the quote
Board games are a marriage of art and functionality
I can appreciate a particular design. I can also appreciate particularly beautiful art. When the two combine, they resonate with me in such a way that the total is greater than the sum. That's when I'm happiest as a gamer.

Another favorite quote, from one of my favorite game designers, Bruno Faidutti, discussing why board games become more popular in a depressed economy:
Games are cheap gifts. They can be given to a whole family, or at least a few brothers and sisters. There are more subtle ones. Board and card games are a social reassuring activity because they bring the generations together when the whole economic and cultural fabric seems to drive them apart. For a few minutes or a few hours, it gives everybody virtual goals, indifferent to a real world we are at a loss to understand and in which our personal goals are often badly compromised. It’s also a nice way to spend a few hours with friends, sitting around a table without talking politics or drinking too much alcohol. In a world that feels more anguishing and tiring than ever, it gives some respite, some rest. But it doesn’t change anything to the real world – it just puts it on hold for a while. Like a party, it’s a good tranquillizer, but not an antidepressant.

And another Faidutti quote, I really like this approach to game design and how he balances luck & skill:
With a game based purely on skill, there is always a risk that it will become more a contest, a kind of competitive exam to sort out who’s the best, rather than a game. This happens almost always in sport, and far too often in other skill games such as chess, go or even trivia games. For me, this breaks the game, because it breaks one of the core elements of gaming – the fact that the game issue is totally irrelevant once the game is over. That’s the reason why I totally stopped playing chess at eighteen, even when I was really good at it, because it felt less and less like a game.

On the other hand, if there’s no skill involved in a game, if it’s pure luck or pure chaos, you cannot even try to win and the game is just not challenging enough to get one’s attention.

So, I try to get the right balance – meaning my right balance – in my designs. I try to design games in which the best skilled player is more likely to win, but never certain to win. One can do this with relying on cards or dice probabilities, or on interaction with other players. I try to use both. For me, a good game is a game in which the winner can think he won because he played well, and the losers can think they lost just because they were unlucky. And it’s even better if they are all right.

And from Wolfgang Kramer:
A good game is a game which you play very often. The more often you play it, the better it is. This is valid for simple and complex games. Family games are games in which the children have the same chance to win as the adults. A good gamer’s game is a complex game, which you can play with different strategies. The different strategies should have the same chances to win – the odds are even.

And finally, from the good doctor Reiner Knizia:
When playing a game, the goal is to win, but it is the goal that is important, not the winning.

I have a microbadge for "Loves all games," and that's not an understatement. My favorite games run the gamut from abstracts (Chess, Hive), euro-style strategy games (Tikal, Power Grid), "ameritrash" style FFG-type games (Runebound (Second Edition), Nexus Ops), even hybrids of the two (Mission: Red Planet, Fire & Axe: A Viking Saga) and innovative card games (Fist of Dragonstones, Biblios). Although not my favorite categories of game, even more traditional card games (such as Lectio) and party games (e.g. Wits & Wagers) I'll occasionally wholeheartedly enjoy when I'm in the right mood. Even within a genre, for example euro, my tastes are for a broad range of mechanics - auctions, area control, economic games, role selection; I'm a game publisher's dream customer! :-) I do have strong preferences as can be seen from my ratings (you'd have to pay me to play Factory Fun again ) - but I find, more often than not, that I'm one of the less picky ones when it comes to game selection on game nights.
I enjoy being a "game sommelier," suggesting just the right game for the mood, interests and number of players.

A few words about my game info...

My "Hot 10" (see lower right) are games I have never played but am most eager to try out.
I've decided to make more of an effort to my Hot 10 games played. I'm keeping track of the first time I play them here since once a game gets played a new one will rotate into the Hot 10.

Hot 10 Games Played in 2015

"Play-Again 10"
Note: I use my Hot 10 exclusively for unplayed games, so this list is for games I am eager to get to the table again.
1. Belfort
2. Uchronia
3. El Grande with King & Intrigue Expansion
4. Shear Panic
5. Glory to Rome
6. Confucius
7. Trajan
8. Notre Dame
9. Isla Dorada
10. Village
11. Ys

"Play-Again 10" Games Played in 2015

I have a "quest" to try all of the BGG Top 10 (yeah probably needs to be updated to the new Top 10 whistle):

Try all of the BGG Top 10 (1 to go)
1. Twilight Struggle: 9.5/10
2. Puerto Rico: 7.5/10
3. Agricola: 7.8/10
4. Through the Ages: A Story of Civilization: 6.2/10
5. Power Grid: 10/10
6. Le Havre: 7.8/10
7. Dominion: Intrigue: 6.5/10
8. Brass: Untried
9. Dominion: 6.5/10
10. Caylus: 7.8/10

Current unplayed games in my collection (Includes base games and expansions):
As of 2/1/11 36 out of 99 (36%; played 63).
As of 2/19/11 43 out of 108 (40%; played 65).
As of 11/20/11 50 out of 118 (42%; played 68).
Starting 2015, BASE ONLY (since I don't record plays of expansions)
As of 3/31/15 64 out of 155 (41%; played 91).

My favorite game designers:
"Old Guard" - the first designers I got into.
Bruno Faidutti
Reiner Knizia
Wolfgang Kramer (especially his Michael Kiesling collaborations)
"The Next Generation" - first newer designer I really dug - heir apparent to Reiner Knizia?
Stefan Feld

Nominees for Best New-to-Me Game of 2016:
-Pandemic Legacy: Season 1

Previous Best New-to-Me Games of the Year:
(Click on the "year" link to see my Top 10 for that year)
2008: Mission: Red Planet (Bruno Cathala & Bruno Faidutti, 2005, Asmodee)
2009: Wallenstein (Dirk Henn, 2002, Queen Games)
2010: Hansa Teutonica (Andreas Steding, 2009, Z-Man Games)
2011: Dungeon Twister 2: Prison (Christophe Boelinger, 2009, Ludically)
2012: Belfort (Jay Cormier & Sen-Foong Lim, 2011, Tasty Minstrel Games)
2013: Antiquity (Jeroen Doumen & Joris Wiersinga, 2004, Splotter Spellen)
2014: War of the Ring (Roberto Di Meglio, Marco Maggi & Francesco Nepitello, 2012, Ares Games)
2015: Race for the Galaxy (Thomas Lehmann, 2007, Rio Grande Games)
Microbadges for JohnnyDollar
Award mbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmb
BGG mbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmb
Board Game Related mbmbmbmbmbmbmb
Board Games mbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmb
Comics mbmb
Contest (Official) mbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmb
Food and Related mbmb
Interests mbmb
Language mb
Literature and Arts mbmb
Misc mbmb
Music mb
Places mb
Pop Culture mbmbmbmbmb
Profession mbmb
Special mbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmb
Sports mb
VGG mb
User Details for JohnnyDollar
Registration Date: 2007-01-18
Last Profile Update: 2016-04-05
Last Login: 2016-05-02
Country: flag United States
State: North Carolina
Town/City: Raleigh
GeekMail: mail Send Private Message to JohnnyDollar
Collection Summary for JohnnyDollar
Board Game
Owned   223
Previously Owned   28
For Trade   3
Want In Trade   406
Want To Buy   1
Want To Play   339
Preordered   1
Wishlist   347
Commented   329
Has Parts   3
Want Parts   0
All   1080
Board Game Expansion
Owned   58
Previously Owned   2
For Trade   0
Want In Trade   71
Want To Buy   0
Want To Play   16
Preordered   1
Wishlist   59
Commented   27
Has Parts   0
Want Parts   0
All   159
Board Game Accessory
Owned   1
Previously Owned   1
For Trade   0
Want In Trade   0
Want To Buy   0
Want To Play   0
Preordered   0
Wishlist   0
Commented   1
Has Parts   0
Want Parts   0
All   2
Board Game 9
Board Game Designer 5
Board Game Artist 5
Board Game Publisher 3
Board Game Implementation 3
For Sale 0
Rating 4
Board Game Plays 1405 Total | By Month | Last 30 Days | Chronological
Board Game Expansion Plays 19 Total | By Month | Last 30 Days | Chronological
Board Game Accessory Plays 0 Total | By Month | Last 30 Days | Chronological
Trade Rating (18) Propose A Trade With This User
Board Game Ratings 389
Average Rating 7.40
10 55   (14.1%)
9 94   (24.2%)
8 101   (26.0%)
7 84   (21.6%)
6 28   (7.2%)
5 18   (4.6%)
4 4   (1.0%)
3 3   (0.8%)
2 2   (0.5%)
1 0   (0.0%)
Board Game Expansion Ratings 1
Average Rating 10.00
10 1   (100.0%)
9 0   (0.0%)
8 0   (0.0%)
7 0   (0.0%)
6 0   (0.0%)
5 0   (0.0%)
4 0   (0.0%)
3 0   (0.0%)
2 0   (0.0%)
1 0   (0.0%)
Board Game Accessory Ratings 0
Average Rating 0.00
10 0   (0.0%)
9 0   (0.0%)
8 0   (0.0%)
7 0   (0.0%)
6 0   (0.0%)
5 0   (0.0%)
4 0   (0.0%)
3 0   (0.0%)
2 0   (0.0%)
1 0   (0.0%)
Top 10
#1: Chess
#2: Hansa Teutonica
#3: Carcassonne
#4: El Grande
#5: Wallenstein (first edition)
#6: Lord of the Rings: The Confrontation
#7: Mission: Red Planet
#8: Runebound (Second Edition)
#9: Glory to Rome
#10: Race for the Galaxy
Hot 10
#1: Kaigan
#2: Fresco
#3: Endeavor
#4: Bombay
#5: Snow Tails
#6: Kreta
#7: Tigris & Euphrates
#8: Commands & Colors: Ancients
#9: Star Wars: X-Wing Miniatures Game
#10: Ginkgopolis
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.