User Profile for p4warrior
Kyle
United States
San Diego
California
flag msg tools
designer
Curse your sudden but inevitable action denial!
mbmbmbmbmb
Gaming Preferences


I enjoy:

thumbsup Wargames
thumbsup Classical Euros with high interaction and well-integrated themes
thumbsup Knizias
thumbsup Ameritrash games of all different weights
thumbsup Elegant rule sets resulting in strategic decisions
thumbsup Solo play
thumbsup Trick-takers

I do not generally enjoy:

thumbsdown Pointless complexity
thumbsdown Cult of the new hype
thumbsdown Point buffet games
thumbsdown Over-long games: if it's long it'd better be worth it
thumbsdown Lifestyle games
thumbsdown Worker placement games



Why I Play Old Games


Regarding games, I am of the "cult of the old" philosophy. Essentially, games should be measured in light of the lessons we've already learned from established classics.

I take this tack when approaching new offerings. If a shiny new game comes along that (1) changes something that works for the worse, (2) disregards established design guidelines for the genre, (3) does not do things better than the best games already on the market, it should be rejected or received with skepticism. There is no need to retread old ground, no matter how sparkly the bits. Sometimes, new games measure up, and sometimes they fall short.

I am a writer for Miniature Market's Review Corner.

Life outside Games


I play the bass guitar, disc golf, video games, racquetball, and tennis. I am a follower of Christ and believe His love and the gospel are the answers for our hurting, broken world.

If you're in the San Diego region, jump into the San Diego Guild and find a game night on a day that works for you. PM me if you'd like to trade or meet up for some games.

When we realize a constant enemy of the soul abides within us, what diligence and watchfulness we should have - John Owen



BGG Ratings


While I do take the BGG system into account, the following guidelines tend to be true of my ratings as well:

d10-1d10-0 -- A "10" is nearly perfect to me, a work of art, a standard for the industry in its respective genre.

d10-9 -- This is a game I love but perhaps recognize a few design flaws in.

d10-8 -- A great game. This may not achieve "9" because of design, my own taste preferences, burnout, or a need for more plays to further evaluate.

d10-7 -- A "7" is kind of my default "pleasant experience" score, and 7's often need to be bumped up or down after further plays. If I keep it here, it's a good game.

d10-6 -- Usually either a flawed game or one I'm just not usually interested in playing, even if it's good otherwise.

d10-5 -- Has lots of flaws or just something I'd usually turn down.

d10-1 - d10-4-- 4 and below are "bad" games, broken games, games I don't want to play. "1"s aren't games at all.

caravan#JustGeekThingscaravan


Quote:
One time I awoke from a trance where I thought I had been living in the fertile crescent in ancient times for 2 weeks, when really I had just been playing a Knizia game.


Quote:
We shall thrift at lunch, we shall thrift on the streets and alleys, we shall thrift with sagging Expedits and thinning wallets in our pants; we shall defend our territory, whenever the sales may be. We shall thrift in the Amvets, we shall thrift in the Deserets, we shall thrift at yard sales and in the fleas, we shall thrift in the malls; we shall never surrender.


Coren wrote:
This game is broken! Quick--Put it on KICKSTARTER!


Quote:
How many times should we shuffle our decks, Herr Knizia? Seven times?

Nay, but seventy times seven!


Coren wrote:
When I have issues with friends or family, I always turn to hobby websites to ask how to resolve them.


Coren wrote:
Curse your sudden but inevitable action denial!


Coren wrote:
Having never played any of these games, I'll restrict my conversation to the variants forum.


Sagrilarus wrote:
The less money you spend on Coup the better.


Circus Maximus Rules wrote:

It is in the best interests of an enjoyable game for all concerned to quicken the pace so as to both shorten the playing time, and more closely reflect the lightning reflexes needed by a charioteer.

Despite some initial complaints, ultimate player enjoyment will be greatly increased by ridding the game of those inevitable plodding players who seem to take forever to make their moves.







Microbadges for p4warrior
Award mbmbmbmbmbmbmbmb
BGG mbmbmbmbmbmb
Board Game Related mbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmb
Board Games mbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmbmb
Comics mb
Contest (Official) mbmb
Ideas mbmbmbmb
Music mbmb
Pop Culture mb
Role-Playing Related mb
Special mb
Sports mbmb
Support mb
User Details for p4warrior
Registration Date: 2012-06-20
Last Profile Update: 2015-08-08
Last Login: 2015-09-04
Country: flag United States
State: California
Town/City: San Diego
Website: http://www.pressxordie.com
GeekMail: mail Send Private Message to p4warrior
Steam Account: p4warrior
Collection Summary for p4warrior
Board Game
Owned   181
Previously Owned   224
For Trade   78
Want In Trade   44
Want To Buy   0
Want To Play   62
Preordered   0
Wishlist   57
Commented   419
Has Parts   1
Want Parts   2
All   610
Board Game Expansion
Owned   6
Previously Owned   11
For Trade   2
Want In Trade   2
Want To Buy   0
Want To Play   0
Preordered   0
Wishlist   3
Commented   13
Has Parts   0
Want Parts   0
All   25
Fandom
Marketplace
For Sale 0
Sold 5
Rating 1
Plays
Board Game Plays 2033 Total | By Month | Last 30 Days | Chronological
Board Game Expansion Plays 25 Total | By Month | Last 30 Days | Chronological
Trades
Trade Rating (47) Propose A Trade With This User
Ratings
Board Game Ratings 427
Average Rating 6.30
10 6   (1.4%)
9 27   (6.3%)
8 87   (20.4%)
7 117   (27.4%)
6 83   (19.4%)
5 35   (8.2%)
4 27   (6.3%)
3 26   (6.1%)
2 16   (3.7%)
1 3   (0.7%)
Board Game Expansion Ratings 15
Average Rating 6.37
10 0   (0.0%)
9 0   (0.0%)
8 5   (33.3%)
7 6   (40.0%)
6 0   (0.0%)
5 1   (6.7%)
4 1   (6.7%)
3 1   (6.7%)
2 1   (6.7%)
1 0   (0.0%)
Top 10
#1: Lord of the Rings
#2: Acquire
#3: Band of Brothers: Screaming Eagles
#4: Last Night on Earth: The Zombie Game
#5: DungeonQuest (third edition)
#6: Lost Cities
#7: Tigris & Euphrates
#8: Wizard
#9: Daytona 500
#10: Carcassonne
Hot 10
#1: B-17: Queen of the Skies
#2: Wizard
#3: Eldritch Horror
#4: DungeonQuest (third edition)
#5: Pokémon Trading Card Game
#6: Blue Moon Legends
#7: Bridge
#8: Boots on the Ground
#9: Tigris & Euphrates
#10: Raj
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.